!-- Begin Web-Stat code 2.0 http -->

Thursday, March 7, 2013

Averaging out the Odds




Averaging out the Odds

Gurcharan Das in his prismatic book from 2009, meditates on  “The subtle art of dharma”, meaning very many versions of the truth based on one’s perspective and changing circumstance.
In “The difficulty of being good”, Das holds that the key weakness of Capitalism is “Greed”, while that of Socialism is “Envy”.  It is of course difficult to say whether India is Capitalist or Socialist, but we do exhibit both traits in ample measure.

Being that something other, has its own complications. And it can’t be wished away under a veneer of genteelness. The weakness of the indefensible must then be obfuscated using statistical jugglery.

At least, this is true if you belong to the UPA.  And you won’t let any other version, for example the CAG’s,  put you off your propagandist course. Instead you will heap calumny on the CAG, and impute motives, and even see its head as allied to the BJP.

Prime Minister Manmohan Singh recently used a misleading game of averages. He used it as the centre piece of his reply to the President’s speech. Of course the whole effort was to try and deflect attention from the economic mess his Government finds itself in.

He compared the  UPA’s nine years in power to the NDA’s six, before triumphantly concluding that despite the current downturn, UPA had managed an average of 7.9% per annum, while the NDA never exceeded 6%.

It can always be counter-argued that the first term of UPA, from 2004 to 2009, in which the GDP rate was higher, was essentially riding on the momentum created by the NDA .  There was also the little matter of the near collapse of the Western economies in 2008.

But what could have been an opportunity for India to seize, as China has since 2008 - was frittered away. India deliberately choked off liquidity, resulting in a slowing of business and industry. A slowing that has now matured to a full stop, with no investments being made towards future growth.

And no attempt is being made even now to set things right. Most of the media seems to accept this presentation, and a majority of the voting public can’t understand economics anyway.

But Conservative  observers, both Indian and foreign, have concluded that a Government that expects to cut the fiscal deficit to 4.8% of GDP from the current5.2%,  while raising overall budgeted expenditure by 16 to 17%, is unlikely to succeed.

For the moment however, the international rating agencies such as Moody, Fitch etc. are giving the budget a chance to work.

The main thrust may well be, though it wasn’t spelled out, in the reduction of subsidies generally and on petroleum products in particular. But the saved money, certainly hundreds of thousands of crores, will go straight out again, on the welfare programmes, while sharply stoking inflation via the transportation sector.
But by the time all this comes to proof, the year will be over, the general elections will have taken place, and it will either be someone else’s problem or the newly triumphant UPA will not have to worry about it anyway.  

Truth be told, the country’s finances are in dire straits, because we are spending much more than we are earning. And if this keeps up, we will certainly drop out of the reckoning in BRICS and start resembling any of the profligate borrow- and-spend Western economies that are going to be in some form of recession for decades.

This despite all efforts to cheer themselves up by a manic clutching at  straws. That is why Dow is rallying, ostensibly on some better employment numbers. But it is only a sympathy rally, to one that began in China, and took in most of the world.

The new leadership in China has announced a spending spree; on defence, on infrastructure, on manufacturing. And since China has massive reserves of money, there will be a knock-on positive effect felt globally. After all, China is called the Number 2 economy now, given its growth statistics, and not Japan.
But India is sliding off the map meanwhile, fading into the obscurity it subconsciously craves; with its developmental expenditure largely stalled. This,  while its Prime Minister stands in the Lok Sabha busy congratulating himself and his Government.

And he didn’t say a word on corruption, though Mr. Modi’s “deemak” remark alluded to it plainly. Defending the indefensible with statistics hasn’t quite figured out how to include scams in the averages. But perhaps next time the prime minister can run up statistics to say my  UPA scams are smaller than NDA ones. And hope to God that the public believes him in his desperation.
  
(774 words)
7th March, 2013
Gautam Mukherjee

Tuesday, March 5, 2013

The Flight of Icarus: Millionaire to would-be Billionaire


BOOK REVIEW

 

FALLEN ANGEL   The Making and Unmaking of Rajat Gupta
Author: Sandipan Deb
Publisher: Rupa Publications India Pvt. Ltd. 2013
Price: Rs. 295/-

The Flight of Icarus: Millionaire to would-be Billionaire

Author of this book, FALLEN ANGEL etc. Mr. Sandipan Deb, is also a graduate of both the IIT and IIM, definitely the toughest colleges in India to get into; and graduate out of. Deb has also written another book entitled The IITians: The Story of an Extraodinary Indian Institution and How Its Alumni Are Reshaping the World. Yes, he likes very long titles and is very proud of the IITs.

Mr. Deb, as former Managing Editor of Outlook, Editor of the Financial Express, and founder-editor of Open, is expected to write well, and this book is very good indeed. Not only is it a page-turner but  is crisply written and well-researched.

Having said that, Mr. Deb, perhaps from a sense of correctness or IITian solidarity, refuses to take sides. This is a tale of an apparent enigma, but perhaps it is not such a mystery after all. Mr. Rajat Gupta is revealed as  an orphaned, self-made paragon of virtue, with a distinguished career, who nevertheless messes it all up in semi- retirement in his mid-sixties.

The question is asked again and again: did Rajat Gupta blot his copybook from a lust to join the league of billionaires? Answer: probably yes. He had long decades advising billionaires, but ended up with oodles of prestige but a modest asset profile of under $150 million. Not only that, the attempt to elevate himself to the billionaire club had a pathetic neediness about it, and lacked Mr. Gupta’s  customary unperturbed finesse. And so, it got him into the trouble he’s in.   

Were there any classic missteps on Mr Gupta’s part?  Oh yes, when he could have got away clean with a slap on the wrist, Mr. Gupta took the Government to Court over a small fine.  And the US Government taught him a lesson; proving the case against him, ruining his reputation, and convicting him, with a jail sentence to boot.

Gupta has had a long career in McKinsey & Co. after passing out of Harvard Business School. He rose to be voted in as Managing Director for three consecutive terms, till 2003. The Teflon, that apparently coated him, protected him, even as several firms McKinsey advised during his years at the helm, went down in flames. These included Enron, Kmart, Swissair, and a host of dotcom start-ups that went bust later, with whom McKinsey had shareholding in lieu of part-of-fee deals. But all the while, because McKinsey knew when to get out with its money, its revenues went up from $1.2 billion to $3.4 billion, in the nine years Gupta was Managing Director.

Gupta stayed an eminent person post 2003, young, sought after. He continued to advise various weighty entities, some in philanthropic areas of health and education, and sat on several boards, including that of Goldman Sachs.

And it was specifically the insider information on Goldman Sachs that Mr. Rajat Gupta allegedly supplied to Mr. Raj Rajaratnam of Galleon Hedge Fund, that led to his conviction and jail sentence and his Icarus-like plunge from grace.

This book also asks the question: did he do it on purpose? But once again Mr. Deb cops out and lets the jury, made up of working class New Yorkers, and Judge Jed S Rakoff do the dirty. And they decidedly pronounced him guilty, based on circumstantial evidence, yes, and on some damaging Government wiretaps.

Fact is, Gupta was clearly angling for a top job with Rajaratnam’s Galleon, at first with its to- be- launched International avatar, and hopefully later, in the flagship company itself. Mr. Gupta’s patrician dealings with the swashbuckling Rajaratnam, a multi-billionaire to Mr. Gupta’s $138 million in assets, over a decade his junior, put him at a considerable psychological disadvantage. It even lost him $ 10 million in bad investments.

But Mr. Rajat Gupta was no stranger to risky bets. But this time was different. He was playing with his own money, on his own time, staking his personal reputation. And he had hitched his wagon to a decidedly reckless player.

And so, when Rajaratnam went down, with a sentence of 11 years in jail for insider trading, it is not surprising that Mr. Gupta, despite his halo, caught at least two. Besides, both were betrayed to the authorities by quite a cast of henchmen.

In the unlikely event Rajat Gupta is let off on appeal in future, his career, what’s left of it, will never recover from this mauling.  The whole debacle could also be seen as bad luck, because it is certainly true  that many people have managed to get away with much worse.

But despite his decades in the US, Mr. Rajat Gupta is not really an insider. Neither is Tamil Sri Lankan Raj Rajaratnam. And Rajaratnam’s Galleon was probably seen to be flying the Jolly Roger much too blatantly, this while interloping, a long way away from home.

(809 words)
March 5th, 2013
Gautam Mukherjee

Sunday, March 3, 2013

The Puritanical Streak



The Puritanical Streak

The West has been convulsed periodically with bouts of extreme morality. And though this is not an everyday occurrence, some of its public probity laws are moored in this puritanical ethic. An uncompromising stance determined to rain retribution on the wrong doer. But this is at considerable variance with, and in contrast to, its own general behaviour and the beliefs that animate them.

In the US and the UK, countries we take a lot of our legal cues from; the public likes to hold public figures to a much tougher sexual regimen than it prescribes for itself. So, essentially promiscuous people, members of the general public, in a modern and permissive culture, will think nothing of pulling down a married aspirant to public office found to be straying from the path of fidelity.  

Similarly, the US laws on insider trading are such, that it makes you think the whole of Wall Street before contrition hit it in 2008, must surely be guilty of violating them. And yet, when someone is caught, he is not spared. This even if it is with the use of wiretaps in insider trading cases, not previously taken cognisance of in a US Court of Law.

And so Mr.  Rajaratnam, the flamboyant billionaire ethnic Sri Lankan boss of the erstwhile Galleon Hedge Fun d, was convicted and sent to jail for 11 years. And unless his Appeal gets him off, so will Indian Mr. Rajat Gupta of McKinsey & Co. fame, and various other parts, who stands both convicted and sentenced to jail too.

But it makes one feel sorry for both, and indeed other lesser associates who fell victim to the somewhat overdone Insider Trading Laws, because they were certainly not the exception.

Because inside information is almost the very thing businessmen employ to make their financial bets all the time. They spend time and money and influence acquiring insights. It is the quality of their information, albeit covertly and discreetly arrived at, backed by their ability to take risk, that has the potential to both make their fortune or ruin them.  

If this is so shocking, why do civilised nations have Intelligence operatives and Covert Operations experts at all? People who are specifically tasked with breaking the rules in pursuit of national objectives.

Almost every real estate acquisition, a repository of wealth,  especially that of land, is based on knowledge of the future development plans for the area. The earlier one gets in on the act, the greater the pay off. Even those who come into the secondary market soon enough are benefited. And yet, at the centre of such transactions, there are a small number of people acting on privileged information. Is this really wrong?

India is heading the same way as the US and the UK, as SEBI, our stock market regulator, seeks to tighten both Insider Trading Laws and Corporate Governance. The latter, by prescribing niceties such as Relationship Agreements between the promoters of corporations, even majority owners, in a public listed company, and their companies.

The idea, already implemented in the UK, attempts to restrict the influence of the owners in the day-to-day workings. It is a bizarre and prudish idea that has not helped the companies in the UK cover themselves in any special glory as a consequence. It also defies common sense.

The intention, of course, is to prevent owners from benefiting at the expense of diversified common shareholders. But Relationship Agreements of this sort ignore the blood and sweat that the entrepreneurs have put into developing their enterprises to public issue in the first place!

And if a majority owner is not to try and control his company, how can it be right for minority owners and independent directors and the like with no real stake in its survival to do so?

It is the stuff and nonsense of the puritanical ethic creeping into perfectly red- blooded enterprise, destined to put a spanner in the works. This sort of unnecessary oversight often introduces suspicion where it does not belong. For us in India, we think we are adopting a “global practice”, but may find we are buying nothing but trouble and strife.  Besides, as to its efficacy, anywhere, including India, the jury is bound to be out.

Similarly, India is seeking to tighten its Insider Trading Laws, and again SEBI is undertaking an exercise to determine how best to do this, for the first time in five years.

Bottom line, it seems to some that we are complicating our lives, just because others in the UK and the US have already done so. And we truly ought to worry about aping the ways of a system that has failed.

(782 words)
March 3rd, 2013
Gautama Mukherjee

Saturday, March 2, 2013

Dynastic Enterprises Limited




Dynastic Enterprises Limited

Several commentators have pointed out that the legitimately elected Lok Sabha has nevertheless turned into a dynastic club.  Electoral Politics is an expensive business, and having a “family firm” in play makes all the difference. Second, and sometimes third generation politicians assume their “family seats”, sometimes after the elevation to higher office, retirement or demise of the parent, and sometimes not.

Editor-in-chief of the Indian Express Mr.Shekhar Gupta, in a recent editorial, pointed out that the dynastic reach of each element of this progression threatens to run into each other like bumper cars at the fair. This has severely proscribed the pan-Indian appeal and vote gathering ability of the original “elected” dynasts, the Nehru-Gandhis.

But as without, so within; with quite a few lesser Congress dynasties also very much a part of the equation. They are there perhaps for their familiarity and assumed know- how , being to the manner born. Or as Mr. Gupta states, because there is no effective mechanism for a new entrant to make the cut. And a certain amount of lazy complacency. Fellow dynasts tend not to dwell on their raison d etre and rarely pose a threat to the High Command.

That this might isolate the comfy oligarchy from the people they presume to lead has not found any champions to its cause, except via the time- tested device of lip-service.

Mr. Rahul Gandhi did talk reassuringly of selecting and developing 50 meritorious people from the grass-roots in every Congress state organisation, each capable of becoming chief minister one day. But he presumably missed the irony of his own elevation to the Vice Presidency for little reason apart from his exalted lineage.

And neither did he say how long he expected the Party to take, in implementing his “Boys from Brazil” type plan of cloning scores of people who were chief minister material. Of course, the Brazil boys  were fictionalised DNA matched clones of Hitler. And I am sure Mr.Rahul Gandhi intends no such thing; for the lack of Hitlerian pliability, if not for any other reason.

Meanwhile, at present, this blatant dynastic carving out of the territory and political landscape will have profound consequences in the forthcoming Assembly and General Elections. The process has embedded itself and gathered both heft and momentum. Many a regional satrap intends to win in his home turf and leverage it to secure further spoils at the Centre. Others from prominent political families who may not garner enough to form Government at the state level while winning a few seats in the Lok Sabha, are equally diligent about using their numbers to extract benefits from any coalition. Both at State and Centre.

These fish, to extend the piscine imagery, like the Salmon and Hilsa, like to swim upstream.   Their dynastic ambitions, father and son/daughter/sometimes nephew/uncle etc., are in terms of catapulting themselves to both national and state-level power simultaneously. And there will be every option explored to see if one of their number cannot seize the prime ministership itself, given, if it comes to pass, the fragmentation of the election results.

The etiolation, of what Mr. Rahul Gandhi and others refer to as “inner-party democracy”, implies even greater changes in how the Congress Party will be run in the future. Particularly after Mrs Sonia Gandhi with her admirable grip on both the Government and the Party, inevitably, exits the stage.  
But gazing once again at the tip of the pyramid, the Gandhis, mother, son and daughter, and perhaps the problematic and somewhat embarrassing son-in-law too, can barely win, that too not without challenge from local scions, their seats in Amethi and Rae Bareilly.

Their real present value to the Congress Party has coalesced into their ability to  provide the cement of cohesion and the discipline of constituting a High Command. Curiously, everyone, from mighty ministers of great experience and ability, to the ordinary rank and file, accept  the authority of the Gandhis as the last word.

This even though it is debatable whether the Gandhi family has a vision for the economic and political progress of the country in 2013. They have an old- style hankering for an absolute majority, and ideas derived from  yesterday’s brand of Socialism. It is perhaps ironic that not many of Mr. Rajiv Gandhi’s modernising initiatives are taken forward with any great enthusiasm.

For the pressing matter of winning elections in the Congress Party, it is, and has been for some time, “every man for himself”, with the successful politicians having to make sure they nurse their constituencies.
 Of course, those who enter Parliament, even high office, via the Rajya Sabha, whether elected by sponsorship, or nominated likewise, do not have the sea-legs of a grassroots presence. They too are a general source of weakness and dependency in an already twisted political dynamic. Sometimes,   it can be argued, a weak central leadership, no longer able to “sway” the country, may prefer political non-entities to surround themselves with. This plays its part in the politics of sycophancy, with no objective thinking possible from such courtiers.

The plethora of competing vested interests reduces the national discourse in parliament to populism and vote- bankism. There is also the matter of many of them check-mating each other. The BJP and the CPM are less afflicted by this phenomenon, but both have suffered from a lack of focus as a consequence, with in-fighting more prominent instead.

Some regional parties with heads who do not have children or close relatives or “friends” to promote,  are nevertheless run like tight proprietorships. Every other recruit to the fold, however eminent otherwise, is reduced to a role in the chorus line.

Clearly then, The Congress Party, and by implication, large parts of the Congress manned  Government, is in a period of transition, likely to come into increasing prominence as the future unfolds.

Meanwhile, they see the demonising of the principal Opposition by calling them “Communal”, if possible every day, as their best bet for continuance in power. The Congressman’s rhetoric becomes even more shrill when he reflects on the very real possibility of Mr. Narendra Modi challenging the much weakened Gandhis, and leading the charge for a national alternative.

Despite a concerted effort to malign the development oriented Chief Minister of Gujarat,  the tide is turning in his favour. This more so, as the UPA has made a complete mess of the economy, poorly managed basic law and order, and seen the rise of corruption to unprecedented levels. Besides, the bachelor Mr. Modi, known for his probity, has no possibility of adding to the list of dynasts that seek to rule us in perpetuity.

(1,102  words)
March 3rd, 2013
Gautam Mukherjee
  

Thursday, February 28, 2013

Above all, do no harm


Above all, do no harm

Lord Meghnad Desai, formerly at the helm of the famous London School of Economics, (LSE), hoped, in morning discussions, that the Finance Minister wouldn't rock the boat, saying : "Above all, do no harm".
Amongst the procession of the high and mighty from politics and commerce, the eminence grises, economic journalists, trade-body and stock market representatives etc. that followed with their comments, no one ventured to express high expectations.

And they were not disappointed. As it turned out, despite the deluge of relatively modest numbers and allocations to a large number of headings, one of the most pedestrian budgets in recent years followed.
It didn't do the kind of harm that Mr. Pranab Mukherjee's budget did, with his retrospective tax ideas, intended taxation of mergers and acquisitions of foreign companies with operations in India and going after those who appeared to be deliberately using loop holes to avoid tax, including foreign companies operating in India.

It tried instead to assume a posture of being pro-poor, pro- women and pro- infrastructure for the poor; but the credibility of the UPA Government's ability to deliver is so low, that no one was the least bit impressed.  But no doubt, the UPA will take the provisions of the budget out to the hustings to try and scare up votes in its favour when the time comes.

This must be the intent, particularly in the year or so left to go before general elections. But one can’t be blamed for being puzzled by the lack of passion.
However, this budget, is unlikely to please any of the target constituents. It is inadequate in every respect and cannot satisfy either in terms of allocations made, or in being administratively likely to provide very much in the short time left.

Mr. Chidambaram manfully kicked the ball on General Tax Avoidance  down the road to 2016. In fact, most of the intentions expressed in Mr. Pranab Mukherjee's 8th and final budget as Finance Minister have been reversed by Mr. Chidambaram in his own 8th budget presentation.

This bears the shadow seal of the prime minister who allegedly didn't think much of retrograde moves that drove away foreign investors at a time when growth itself was faltering.

We have had a slowing economy for some time now, and relatively gloomy forward projections, because even a 6% GDP growth level is insufficient to take care of the country's burgeoning needs. Particularly its welfare programmes, which  continue unabated. The overall expenditure though, already at a high Rs. 16.75 trillion, was hiked by a further 16% in the budget to suit.

There was nary a murmur of downsizing the Government, or tightening its belt. Instead a number of indirect taxes were imposed on the middle class to finance, or in fact, partially finance, the growth in expenditure. This back-door taxation was akin to the freight- rate hike and hike in reservation fees announced in the railway budget.

And these did not spare such everyday middle class items such as set-top boxes, cellphones, eating out at restaurants and flats being purchased which were larger than 2,000 sq.ft.. Neither did it spare the SUVs of the aspirational.

But there was no attempt at widening the tax base. For symbolic effect, because it is unlikely to yield much from the 42,800 people with declared taxable incomes of over Rs. 1crore, out of more than 1.3 billion people- there is a 10% IT surcharge on them, and a bump- up of corporate taxes as well.

The bulk of the thrust was on indirect taxes that the middle-class, some 350 million people, cannot escape.
The Finance Minister of Dream Budget fame in 1997 with his espousal of the Laffer Curve to bring in more willing tax payers was present today; but only in so far as he didn’t venture into death duties and a more onerous wealth tax.

All in all, this timid budget will not win the forthcoming assembly and general elections for the UPA. Neither will it annoy the intelligentsia or business particularly, because it lacks sharp edges. The stock market will continue to languish unenthused and the FIIs will wait and watch.

And none of the big ticket issues, such as inflation, growth, or revival of business, industry, infrastructure, the great common weal for that matter, will be touched by this budget. FDI will wait till after 2014.

This budget has been labelled “prudent” by many, mopping their brows in relief that it hasn’t set out to do serious damage. But it makes one wonder what the Government is most afraid of. Could it be change, let alone transformation?

(766 words)
February 28th, 2013
Gautam Mukherjee

Tuesday, February 26, 2013

Another Pauperising Railway Budget



Another Pauperising Railway Budget

Union Railway Minister Pranav Kumar Bansal quoted Kautilya to emphasise the importance of Artha or money to any enterprise. It made one sit up in hope, expecting him to make strong moves to restore the railway’s financial health.

But it was only so much flattery to deceive with other couplets of poetry strewn about as well. Praise for Mr. Bansal’s tepid efforts came only from partisan supporters such as Finance Minister Chidambaram and Prime Minister Manmohan Singh, who made the surreal comment that it was “reformist”.

In the end, Mr. Bansal made much of wiping out the Indian Railway overall losses of Rs. 24,000 crores. But, his ambition is limited to putting about Rs. 30,000 crores back into the till by 2014. The entire budget speech smacked of unrealistic, unconvincing aspiration, long laundry-lists of detail, but  was abjectly timid in real terms.  

Mr. Bansal made announcements on many additional facilities, factories and trains, carefully ignoring Opposition ruled states, and spoke improbably of raising an unprecedented amount of Rs. 100,000 crores via the often problematic PPP method. 

He was also selling everyone short, or has set himself very low standards, when he put a figure of a mere Rs. 94,000 crores towards the requirement for development! The UPA II Government seems self- satisfied with tinkering at change and ignores transformation altogether .  It has taken the annual nature of the Railway Budget much too literally, and is quite opaque on the need   for continuity of progress.

 The Indian Railways are hardly fit for the 21st century, one needs to see any modern railway system abroad for this point to be driven home. And with the recent sharp deterioration in safety and security, and other standards, large tranches of the better-off  middle classes have abandoned train travel altogether in favour of aeroplanes.   

Yet the Government, its Railway Minister and senior Railway Board officials, brazenly indulged in statistical jugglery to talk of declining accident rates. If there are hundreds of obscure train routes, they do help to dilute the statistics on routine accidents and deaths caused thereby on most, if not all the busiest routes! To boldly emphasise this sophistry is to insult the intelligence of ordinary people. Law and order on board trains, replete with muggings, robberies, rapes and murder, is also increasingly common.

Ours may be a large, if not the largest, railway network in the world, but it is highly antiquated and redolent of the colonial period. And the modernist moves such as e-ticketing and wi-fi on select trains, while most welcome, resemble the effort to keep the doughty Ambassador car going.

 Adding Isuzu engines, power brakes, better wiring and some limited electronics, do not still a modern car make. The fact is, it is a chariot from the fifties and retrofitting it is the first cousin to nostalgia. It makes little sense.

Similarly, the first Railway Minister from the Congress Party after 17 years did not venture to increase passenger fares even as he cited, multiple times, the costs of services were outstripping income at every turn.
Raising freight rates is inflationary, but it has been done.  Raising passenger fares is not, but it was not done, stating that they have been raised recently. But that was a minimal increase, and one needs to do it almost as often as the change in diesel, petrol and LPG. An attempt to align just petroleum price hikes has been attempted on freight rates, but many other things need to be brought up- to- date to cope.

Mr. Bansal has decided to raise marginally more revenue, raising freight rates by 5% on average. This is not enough to even meet rising costs, let alone modernise freight handling systems and processes. However, rates for reservations on tatkal basis, and on superfast trains, have thankfully been hiked. But because the vast majority of rail travellers are not being made to pay more, neither can the services be improved for them.

Sixty- seven new express trains have been added, but nothing has been earmarked for the updating of infrastructure. New trains have been announced, assuming that they actually see the light of day, they must perforce run on the age-old rails. This, and ancient signalling equipment etc. is what compromises safety along with free access to undesirable elements.

The sacking of Gopalganj station in Madhya Pradesh, minutes after the Railway Minister finished his speech today, after two children were killed in yet another railway accident, is a fitting cameo. Our stations are only fit for period films set before WWII. The Great Indian Railway has lost its romance as it struggles for survival in inadequate hands.

(771  words)
February 26th, 2013
Gautam Mukherjee

Saturday, February 23, 2013

Banking See Banking Do


Banking see Banking do

The Government has announced the licensing of new private “high-street” banks, with a much wider qualifying net, with up to 49% foreign holding, up from 26% previously allowed. This is a good thing as there is a considerable shortage of banks that lend money to worthwhile private enterprise and risk their arm with funding start-ups.

 Presumably, there will be less official dictation on whom they can lend to, though it would be a departure from the Government’s/bureaucracy’s way if it is indeed so. They intend to let the authorities, that is the RBI, the CBI, the CBDT etc. to go into the background and vet who can qualify to be licensed. But at least all sorts of entities, including existing NBFCs, can now apply.

There will also be safeguards that will seek to prevent the promoters from taking in deposits and vanishing. Though, of course, they could always give the money to proxies to exactly the same effect.  There will also be reasonable shareholding norms of up to 40% for 12 years and not less than 15% thereafter, so that the original promoters, don’t start trading in the banks and bank licenses themselves. And good enough seed capitalisation standards too, to make sure the banks have depth and commitment.

Successful licensees will also be required to list their banks on the stock exchanges within 3 years implying some degree of public shareholding. They will also have to put in 25% of their branches in rural areas that don’t have banks yet. This is a condition that is likely to prove lucrative as long as the new private banks know how to simultaneously do business with the base of the pyramid. A kind of “nano”, “micro” or “grameen” banking if you will. The Sahara Parivar owes at least some of its billions to what they call “para-banking” at the grassroots level.

Private entities would be keen on the opportunity principally to access cheap retail funds and the possibility of maximising profit by lending to the best class of borrowers. So here comes Reliance, Tata, L&T, Mahindra-already in it with Kotak, and probably a host of others including, we are told, brokers and builders.

 But let us remember also that all is not well with Indian banking. Non-performing assets (NPAs) are ruling at a record high. They are up over 50% year- on- year in the PSU banks at nearly Rs. 100,000 crores.
Private Banks tend to merge with others of their ilk when they start to go belly up. The existing clutch of private banks licensed mostly in 1993-94, provide quite a few examples. It is basically down to the big three of HDFC, ICICI and Axis presently.  A dozen were licensed, including the new Kotak Mahindra and Yes Bank, as of 2003-04.

And then there are the foreign banks, led by Standard Chartered. The foreign banks have done quite well with NPAs, if not with their own risky investment and treasury management decisions. But not so well with fraud. And banking fraud too has gone up about 42% and accounts for over Rs. 52 crores gone walkabout this year.

The state of our legal system, burdened and clogged by millions upon millions of pending cases, means that the perpetrators of all kinds of financial skulduggery will not come to pay for their sins in less than twenty years at a minimum. And that is only when the prosecution can construct a strong enough case and persist with it.

Actually, reform in one area cannot operate in isolation and is often bottle-necked by unfavourable conditions obtaining in another part of the system. And it is not advisable to modernise on the back of a sea of Government debt.

Our Government borrows massively, but mostly for current expenditure, salaries for its army of unsackable employees, rather than development.  No country with our frustratingly bad administration deserves to carry such a huge Government on its groaning back.
And even if we did put the borrowed money to development, it is probably the wrong method of financing growth. Our erstwhile colonisers, Great Britain, have just lost their AAA rating and now enjoy AA1; a notch less.

This is probably undeserved too, because Britain owes over a trillion pounds sterling, some 70% of GDP at present. Under the Conservatives, the UK is putting in spending cuts of 50 million pounds this year, but it is still not much when the projection is that by 2016 their debt pile will have grown to 96% of GDP.

No, we are much better served to attract FDI and FII to finance our growth and it is high time we realised it. Banking; bigger, better, and more numerous, can surely do its bit.

(786 words)
February 23rd, 2013
Gautam Mukherjee