!-- Begin Web-Stat code 2.0 http -->

Thursday, March 21, 2013

A Zephyr Of New Ideas For India


 A Zephyr Of New Ideas for India

Mr. Narendra Modi, consciously addressing an audience of sophisticated Indians and the world beyond, demonstrated considerable tech savvy and comfort  with its possibilities today. He was the first Chief Minister invited to speak on Google’s Big Tent Activate Summit 2013 event for India, part of the series being conducted around the globe.

Here was a silver-bearded young man in his sixties, talking technology with Guinness Book Record achieving ease. And this is not hyperbole, because Modi is indeed entered in the book for using 3D holographic technology for the first time, for such an application. He addressed 53 election meetings at the same time, in what he now called “different geographies”, during his winning 2012 campaign to rule Gujarat for the fourth consecutive term.

As Modi’s 18 plus minutes of address covered how he has employed the internet and land surveying technology to improve the water recharging and ground water levels in Gujarat, the revolutionary virtues of two way and interactive communication now made possible via the internet, using GIS technology to fine tune fund allocations to hospitals, and so on, he gave vibrant meaning to Bob Dylan’s enigmatic line that said: “Ah, but I was so much older then, I’m younger than that now”.

Speaking in accented but reasonably fluent English, Mr. Modi,  grown from an RSS Pracharak and a modest OBC background, into Gujarat’s celebrated three terms completed and counting Chief Minister, he began by quoting Alvin Toffler of  futurist  classic Future Shock fame.

 Specifically, Mr. Modi spoke of Toffler’s 21st century definition of literacy which is not just being able to read and write and being educated as such, but having the mental dexterity to “learn, unlearn and relearn”.
Modi quoted former President Bill Clinton also, an ace communicator, who has called the Internet “The new  Town Square”. Modi  Indianised the concept to “Nukkad”, all the while reminding one of the sweeping vision of a historic  game- changer like current President Barack Obama.

There were, inevitably, some clever speech written lines, such as the very quotable “IT plus IT is equal to IT”, but the sentiments it stood for, bore the hallmark of Modi’s progressive vision for the future of India and its people.

Modi has, it is evident, not let up on his campaign for the leadership of India ever since his first nationally broadcast speech at the SRCC in Delhi just over a month ago. 

It is clear he fervently believes that the Gujarat model of development is ideal for the rest of India and he wants an opportunity to implement it.

And increasingly, the warm reception to his ideas is indicative of the fact that larger and larger numbers of Indians are heeding his call. But the subtext seems to say people are beginning to regard Narendra Modi as something of a saviour, a messiah come to rescue India from the mess created by the UPA over almost ten years of corrupt and inept misrule.

Modi spoke of “direct democracy” via the net, and the value of “informed citizens” and said it was time to “perform” and not just “promise”. 

This is a new and accountable zephyr, this unfolding Modinama, developing like a gentle summer wind on the threshold of the festival of colours.  

Narendra Modi fully intends to harness more and more technology towards better governance, but this he has already demonstrated in Gujarat. There is greater connectivity, precision, time- saving, interactivity and efficiency there as a consequence.

The bottom line, in Modi’s own words: “the crux of politics lies in connecting to the people”. Narendra Modi has done so very ably in Gujarat. He is now in the process of doing likewise throughout India and overseas.

(612 words)
March 21st, 2013
Gautam Mukherjee

Wednesday, March 20, 2013

The Times They Are A Changing



The Times They Are A Changing

India is now the largest buyer of conventional weapons in the world, practically all of it on an imported basis, routine corruption scams notwithstanding. We are buying to modernise our armed forces, because we face two threats in our theatre, from Pakistan, a perennial problem,  and much more powerful China, a more mysterious  rival for domination of the region, even a counterbalance to the present world order.

Our own arms industry remains at, or near, the starting gate, despite frequent professions of intent from the Government in general and the present Defence Minister AK Anthony in particular. Meanwhile China makes its own nuclear submarines and aircraft carriers.

Union Minister AK Anthony, an abject Gandhi loyalist, whom some say could be considered for the post of PM if UPA forms the Government yet again; is sometimes called, without apparent irony, “Saint Anthony”, for being, it is said, reasonably incorruptible.

But despite his unquestioning loyalty to the Congress High Command, from which he draws his power and stability, he has succeeded in doing absolutely nothing to kick-start our own arms industry in the private sector, let alone bring it up to speed. Possibly because arms deals are amongst the biggest sources of payola for our rulers and their henchmen.

China meanwhile has just displaced the UK as the 5th biggest arms exporter in the world, and this is principally on the back of its exports to Pakistan, which accounts for a fulsome 55% of all Chinese arms exports.  The shrinking of British stature is not surprising and of a piece with its loss of influence globally, but the sophistication and range of  the Chinese armaments industry is impressive for an essentially home grown programme.

Whether Pakistan pays for these Chinese armaments in hard currency, or even on the nail, is another matter. But China knows how to extract its pound of flesh from its client state and proxy India baiter anyway.

Besides it makes Pakistan hopelessly beholden, particularly with the US in the process of pulling out of Afghanistan.

China’s inroads into Baluchistan and a warm-water port on the Arabian Sea bordering the Gulf, POK, in the upper reaches of the Hindu Kush, and even into Afghanistan, with Pakistani good offices preceding, is a form of payment too.

There is also the diplomatic dividend of a tight alliance with the only Muslim nuclear state at present.

Having said that,  China does have its own future to think of, which calls for thinking on a much bigger scale, and out-of-the box enough to realise what worked in the 20th century will not suffice in the 21st. In fact, this is evident already even as we are only in the second decade of the new century.

Quantum exports to the EU and the US are not what they used to be for China, and unlikely to pick up anytime soon. There is only feeble current growth, and a massive overhang of debt that threatens to collapse many of the constituent economies of the EU. The old borrow and spend model is largely discredited and is being pursued with near zero interest rates and easy monetary liquidity only to prevent seizure from sudden withdrawal. All of this applies also to the US with the proviso that it is very much bigger as an economy and more likely to be able to right itself.

Africa too cannot pay China enough in currency terms, but can, and does, hand over large tracts of natural resources that can be developed on very favourable terms. But that too costs massive money that China must provide for the infrastructure development before it can cash in.

The Iranians and other bits and pieces of the Middle East such as Syria, parts of Libya and Egypt and some of the “Jasmine” states leaning towards a radical Muslim hue, essentially hostile to the West, can buy Chinese goods and armaments. But these are largely barter deals. Most of it is in exchange for oil, but their populations, and consequently their appetites, are not too large.  So the balance of trade suffers in any case. 

Asia and the Pacific region is fragmented, over- fished by too many vendors, and that really leaves only India.

The brand new leadership in China, Li just now, and Xi  a little earlier, realise that they need to ramp up the commercial engagement with India which has a vast market of young people and huge pent up demand for very many things China is good at. And this means real confidence building measures with a country that feels inferior after the 1962 licking and ever since. But yet, we could certainly use Chinese collaboration in many areas.

Take for example our quaint railway system, fit only for a remake of “Jewel in the Crown” or  Richard Attenborough “Gandhi”. There is nothing remotely up-to-date about the Indian Railways even though it is ostensibly large enough to warrant ( debatable) a separate budget presentation every year.
   
Our infrastructure building takes forever to build, and the Chinese by contrast are experts at executing mega projects in record time.

For India, it is important not to feel militarily threatened. We have been witnessing an encirclement via our South Asian neighbours, Nepal, Sri Lanka, the unreliable and forever delinquent Pakistan, even Myanmar and Bangladesh, but it is starting to dawn on the Chinese that this policy  is not serving them very well. 

All these client states cannot fill Chinese coffers. They need China much more than China needs them. But India could enrich China, as it can all the countries of the West currently down on their luck.

This can become the basis of a very different kind of entente cordiale between the two Asian giants that account for nearly half the population of the world. 

It is no wonder then that President Xi  is looking forward to meeting our PM Manmohan Singh on the sidelines of the forthcoming BRICS Summit in Durban next week.And why President Xi and Premier Li, both representing a change of the power guard in China, have been signalling a desire to boost bilateral ties with India, which they call one of the “most important”.

It will take us Indians a long overture to trust the Chinese, because we have been there before in the Panchsheel days, only to be roundly thrashed by Chou En Lai and Mao. Besides, proxy Pakistan is in no mood to pipe down. And yet, the future demands a rapprochement that can benefit both countries much more than the present state of wariness.

(1,093 words)
March 20th, 2013
Gautam Mukherjee

Tuesday, March 19, 2013

Cyprus Bailout To Dip Into Russian Loot


Cyprus Bailout To Dip Into Russian Loot

Why so much Russian off-shore money is stacked in the EU’s Mediterranean outpost of Cyprus, rather than in traditional havens like Switzerland is a bit of a mystery. Is it really the “Trojan Donkey” for the Russians in the 17 member EU? Between straight deposits and Russian companies registered and operating out of Cyprus, the exposure is in the region of $60 billion.

Of course, higher returns on investment due to Cyprus’ soft laws, low taxes and offshore haven ways, have something to do with it. Switzerland offers security and stability but not very many of the other bells and whistles.

But there may be quite a few Russian oligarchs getting ready for a haircut and shave on its Cypriot exposure. After the recent Cypriot parliamentary resolution refusing to tax their bank depositors, Cyprus will be looking for a bailout from the Russians instead.

This could work for both. Vladimir Putin has already expressed anger and outrage at the unprecedented demand for Cyprus to pay part of its own bailout requested from Brussels, about half the money needed. And Russia has helped Cyprus in the past and might do so again particularly if Cyprus offers a stake in the development of its offshore oil and gas fields.

The spotlight on Nicosia reveals that of the $27 billion foreign money stacked in Cypriot banks, largely seeking to be laundered on a no- awkward- questions- asked- basis, $19 million is Russian. The laundering does draw India into its ambit because of a treaty with Cyprus, India imposes a low withholding tax on profits in Indian debt and securities, and Cyprus takes no capital gains tax at all. Most FII money into stocks however comes to India via Mauritius.
   
The EU is offering $ 13 billion (Euro 10 billion), to keep the key Nicosia banks from collapsing after they became the 5th country in the Eurozone to ask for a bailout. But instead of footing the bill in its entirety, Brussels has asked Nicosia to come up with 5.8 billion Euros on its own.

This initiative may be emanating from EU’s leading economy, Germany, getting a bit sick of bailing out country after country, albeit after asking for painful austerity measures.

Meanwhile, Cyprus banks are closed while the negotiations continue, but there is already an ATM- based- run. This could get very much worse once they open, later this week or early next week, irrespective of the deal hammered out.

This is quite a dangerous prospect, as copycat bank runs could materialise all over the weaker sections of the EU as depositors try to get their money out of the Government’s reach.

The idea to tax the deposits is not Cypriot.  But this manoeuvre is setting a precedent that is making the rest of the EU jittery too. It is unsettling as an idea because sovereign debt is meant to be sacrosanct. It is traditionally backed by s guarantees and is not meant to be liable to being deleveraged by unilaterally grabbing a slice of the deposited money.

Depositors are, after all, lenders to the banks and the Government. They are actually the White Knights, the bedrock savers that underpin every economy. And they are not the ones who ran up the bill and liabilities at all. They are not usually the borrowers, and not the ones who actually owe the money. 

Since bank and sovereign liabilities all over the EU are at a frightening overhang of 320% of GDP  it is not just the depositors who need to worry.

In the US, the debt liability burden accounts for 83% of the entire economy. This US debt too is a very large sum, amounting to trillions of US dollars, almost in a 1:1 ratio, meaning some 13 trillion dollars in a 15 trillion dollar economy. But at least the debt doesn’t lap the economy three and a quarter times!

However this plays out at this time, the problem is so severe that neither the US nor the Eurozone are going to be in the clear any time soon.
Having said that, the admirable thing is that the economies of the West have been kept afloat ever since 2008, despite such massive challenges. There are, over five years later, signs of economic revival all around, at least on the current account, and in terms of a mild employment revival.

The management of the humungous debt however is the legacy of the past, and will cast a shadow far into the future.

And it is this fact that will shift the balance of power relentlessly to BRICS. And more particularly witness the establishment of China, which is highly solvent, and possibly India, if it changes its deficit financing ways; achieve global economic leadership.

(788 words)
March 20th, 2013
Gautam Mukherjee

Monday, March 18, 2013

Greetings from Stalinistan


Greetings from Stalinistan

The banks are stressed, according to the CII survey recently released. They have massive non-performing assets (NPA), presently the highest they have been in six years. This, combined with  the newly imposed, higher  mandatory capital requirements, will seriously erode their profitability at a minimum.

The much talked about Food Bill, a key thrust area of the UPA Government, on its way to becoming a food guarantee law under  an act of parliament, will place an additional 38.6% burden over and above the currently budgeted  Rs. 90,000 crore  subsidy for next year.

This will, it is reported, shoot up the subsidy to Rs.1,24, 747.1 crores at present prices, for next year alone. Not only are more people being included under its provisions, but there is a demand that the highly subsidised prices be maintained unchanged for 3 years, irrespective of the expectedly higher procurement prices of  the essential grains and cereals covered.

In addition, there is another, equally ambitious programme being developed for providing  guaranteed rural housing to the poor at state expense.

The banks are stressed mostly because of forced loans to economically weaker sections.  And the growing subsidies, transferring from petroleum products towards the public distribution system and so on, threaten to bankrupt the nation.

But, at the same time, it must be acknowledged that they seek to help the poor of this country and that is indeed a laudable objective. The only quarrel that anyone can have with such undeniably lofty ambition is the fiscal responsibility that should accompany such largesse. This is a new phase of affirmative action to help the bottom third of the population, but because it is being done so recklessly by way of straight giveaways, it is likely to cause considerable harm to our viabilities.

That many of these schemes will not fructify in the year or so that this Government will be in power before the general elections, makes them squarely aimed at the electorate. They are designed  to provide campaign talking points, and hopefully restore the UPA to power for a third consecutive term.
But in the event the UPA is not returned to power, as acts of parliament, these programmes will have to be implemented by any successor Government. Of course, it is yet to be seen if these initiatives pass into law in the time remaining.

This kind of institutionalised populism was very au courant in Stalinist Soviet Russia too where the mighty USSR was bankrupted eventually. And while defence spending was also part of the problem, everyday developments, shortages, failures, collapses, run- away inflation, came from the seeds of destruction sown by policies expected to deliver the longed for “dictatorship of the proletariat”.

But instead, the mega programmes largely failed in the implementation, or in the results they yielded.
Judging from the fate of the other huge poverty alleviation schemes instituted   by the UPA Government, these new ones too are likely to be mired in massive corruption, misappropriation and delay. A leopard cannot change its spots just on the basis of a wish, and it is doubtful if the efficacy of such programmes is the main objective at this time anyway.

But regardless, there is an attitude pushing these schemes with an unheeding arrogance. Any kind of Stalinism, post, pseudo or neo, invites sudden death if you disagree, dissent, or arouse suspicion, at least within the Party.  And yes, everything is political in Stalinistan, including economics, and the colours pink, red, green and saffron.

And the prerequisite to running Stalinistan is a simple hold on absolute power with plenty of government agencies that can be used to intimidate, subvert, deny, delay, banish and hound.

Also, the brazen ability to concoct reasons and justifications for the most outrageous circumstances while distracting attention by pouring scorn on and calling all opponents and rivals as many names as possible.

Our Stalinists are often sentimental, given to emotional outpourings that purport to bleed for people at any provocation. Or, like a haemophiliac, for no reason at all, except of course the inability to coagulate blood.

So which atrocity should we speak of first? Is it the sharp rise in new subsidies? Or is it the rampant money- laundering in several private banks? Or shall we talk, yet again of the food inflation? Or laugh at the red herring of becoming a leading manufacturing nation if it manages to account for 25% of GDP?  Or the soft attitude to terrorism, mayhem, corruption, insurgency, diplomatic snubs, law and order collapse? Or should we talk of the Opposition’s failures instead?

(763 words)
March 18th, 2013
Gautam Mukherjee

Saturday, March 16, 2013

The Modi Mantra at the India Today Enclave 2013




The Modi Mantra at India Today Enclave 2013

Narendra Modi speaking to the nation, has something of the legendary cleaning out of the  Augean Stables about it. Hercules too was not expected to succeed by King Augeas who gave him a seemingly impossible task, but he did.

Hercules innovated boldly, redirecting and channelling two nearby rivers into the entrance of the stable, flushing out all the filth via the exit.

 Mr. Modi too, has, over the last 12 years, performed a development miracle in his home state. And he has done it using the same administrative machinery and system as all the others had available to them. His short film on Gujarat’s progress, used at the start of his lecture, demonstrated this almost overwhelmingly with a mass of impressive statistics.

And Mr. Modi’s tone also has a missionary zeal to it, something of Jesus chiding the Pharisees, particularly for their self-serving hypocrisy.

Narendra Modi was relaxed and comfortable in his skin at the Enclave. He did not disappoint. Everything about this occasion was somewhat special. The live audience was august and distinguished, comprising of business and industry leaders, foreign diplomats, professionals, journalists and also, some politicians. They were attentive and more than willing to hear him out. And the entire occasion was broadcast live by Headlines Today TV Channel, and will no doubt be reflected on plentifully elsewhere.

The ringing introduction by Mr. Aroon Purie, Mr. Narendra Modi’s own far from self- effacing speech, and the question and answer session that followed it, was revealing of his vision for the country, and exciting in its forward looking implications.

All of it had the ring of a full-fledged campaign event akin to an American style presidential town-hall meeting, but amongst the high and mighty of the land. It covered a great deal more ground than his speech at SRCC or his address to the Indian diaspora in the US.

It particularly laid out the typical Modi vision of privatisation, good governance, motivation of the administration, people responsiveness, accountability, effectiveness, innovation, and development as a solution to all ills. Mr. Modi also laid out his vision of a uniform polity without special privileges for specific groups and ethnicities.

There was wry humour too, and a jauntiness that denotes confidence in the future of India as part of his vision.   He also clearly indicated that he was speaking his mind with the tacit, if not explicit, backing of his party the BJP.

And the audience in the packed hall listened to Narendra Modi with a degree of fascination, and dawning recognition that this man could well be leading the nation come 2014.

No one else in the Indian political firmament speaks in quite the manner Mr. Modi does, with his tremendous emphasis on change, transformation and a conviction in the power of good governance and development. In Mr. Modi’s case, the lofty vision is not merely rhetorical, because he always returns to the track record of Gujarat to drive home his point.

Mr. Modi reiterated here, as he has before, that he saw “Vikas” as a general solution to all the country’s problems. Not only that, but he did not hesitate to welcome privatisation in various fields, including, for example, the Indian Railways. 

Mr. Modi brought an enthusiasm to his exposition at the Enclave’s Leader’s Lecture that is definitely rare in the mouths of politicians, particularly one that has ruled his state since 2002. He demonstrated an urge to innovate at the national level, transferring the same positivity he has been able to infuse in his state. 

A key takeaway from this unusual man of the hour, is his emphasis, not on endless legislation but on action to deliver results. The fate of India’s progress could well hang on his advent into national politics, and a success at that level that is no less resounding .

(633 words)
March 16th, 2013
Gautam Mukherjee

Wednesday, March 13, 2013

The Black Swan of Indian Reform




The Black Swan of Indian Reform

 Mr. Nassim Nicholas Taleb postulated  the Theory of the Black Swan, initially to explain unexpected financial market events in 2004, and then revised it in 2007, to encompass life- changing phenomena such as the advent of the personal computer,  the internet, the dissolution of the Soviet Union, 9/11 etc. His ideas were much praised after the implosion of the financial markets and the real economies of the US and Europe in 2008.

Black Swan is a metaphor for the outlier and unforeseen phenomenon that has a profound effect on subsequent events and leads to considerable hindsight analysis later. The rear-view mirror analysis too is often inaccurate, as it tries to resolve intellectual and conceptual conflicts by blunting edges and forcing square pegs into round holes. And by claiming the blind-sided events were anticipated after all!

The Black Swan of Reform in India, hiding in plain sight, is the essential conflict between “big government”, and the empowerment of the private sector. Now, big government is more or less embedded in our DNA, enshrined as it was, into our economic thinking from the very commencement of the Republic of India.

 And empowerment of the private sector, collaboration with it, with foreign entities/companies, induction of superior technologies/methods, infusion of capital that we may not have, or be able to allocate as a State, etc. lies at the heart of Liberalisation and Reform.  The implication is - shrink big government which is not ideally suited to enterprise. But, the net effect of Indian Government trying to author Reform is that it comes to the table with a built-in urge to subvert the process, aided and abetted by a media and public that agrees.

This plays out in many ways. Many State and Central Government initiatives to disinvest are criticised for selling the assets for less than their market value, with dark aspersions cast as to the motives.  This is by political opposition, a media and a public, weaned and fed on Socialism, protesting the devolution of wealth and power to the privates - perceived as rapacious, immoral and anti-people. We fail to realise that this attitude comes from long conditioning to be anti-elitist, almost anti-prosperity, even for ourselves.

Similarly, when Industry is competitively attracted to a region by offering sops and land on long lease/ sale on very advantageous terms, there is a hue and cry. The thrust of which is that the State or Central Government Agency concerned has betrayed the interests of the tax payer and squandered public assets.
The fuss completely ignores the idea that Government needs to promote business and industry and facilitate it to make money, generate employment and extend prosperity to larger numbers of people on a viable and sustainable basis.

That the Government is not necessarily meant to regard all enterprise with suspicion, and uphold the principle of social justice that any form of unbridled capitalism is presumably bound to ignore. That it may be unfair to deny, often without justification, that private enterprise has any ideals of Trusteeship or Welfarism in its conduct of affairs.

 Even as we ignore much real evidence of excellent transformation in people’s lives, their environment and possibilities, brought about by our leading business houses such as the Tatas, and indeed many others in the top ten or twenty groupings, such as Reliance, Godrej, Bharti, Mahindras, ITC, Birlas, Infosys, etc.
Is the Government then meant to conduct good business on its own account or stimulate and catalyse other, essentially private enterprise, to do so? Has the Government succeeded in conducting good business except in a monopolistic context where its inefficiencies cannot sink it?

There are many countries clear in their policy direction in this regard, including those in authoritarian regimes in the Middle East. They are quite happy to mentor and spur the private sector. They offer help in various forms, from soft loans to infrastructure, including land, electricity, water, access roads and railhead connectivity, nearby airports, assistance with finding export markets via bilateral agreements and trade treaties and so on.

India however, tends to revert to its “Command and Control” or “Licence-Permit Raj” ways at the first opportunity. After all, most of our top bureaucrats and senior politicians come from our earlier Socialist era. It was a time when we were closely allied to the USSR and overlaid many of their centralised planning and administrative methods on top of a liberal parliamentary framework based on the Westminster model with US republican overtones.  

So Reform promoting legislation still gets interpreted in a manner so that very little of its original intent gets past the trawl-net in the execution. And thus, we have the two-steps-forward-three–steps-back gait of progression on most of our initiatives.

(785 words)
March 14th, 2013
Gautam Mukherjee

Sunday, March 10, 2013

The Economics of India First




The Economics of India First

Mr. Narendra Modi recently told the overseas Indian diaspora that his idea of Secularism involved the notion of “India First”. He explained it in terms of putting the interests of the country above sectarian interests and pressure groupings. What then would this mean in economic terms?

Modi says he has only been re-elected again and again because of his track record on development. Many criticize even this, saying there has not been the kind of job growth one would desire alongside such spectacular absolute growth in investment etc.

But looking at employment growth as a percentage of the total population of the state is misleading, except to illustrate we are still a long way from eliminating poverty.  Different approaches to the statistics however, throw up different highlights, all competing for attention.

The Indian Express reports that Gujarat hires more people via the government run employment exchanges than any other state. The Labour Bureau of Gujarat under the Union Ministry of Labour claims Gujarat and Daman & Diu have the lowest unemployment statistics today.

Other, less sympathetic sources, quote the National Survey done pre-budget 2013, and talk of stagnating percentages in overall employment. The opponents of Modi’s development model carp about the paucity of poverty alleviation measures for those in the poorest quarter of the population. This, without however pointing to the actual success of such bounty anywhere else in the country!

By way of unfavourable comparison though, look at the way the rupee is plummeting because of huge declared and undeclared deficits caused by profligate Central policies. It could touch Rs. 60 to the US dollar soon, and then plummet towards Rs. 75 because of the cost-push inflation raging. There are too many given- away rupees, our new form of want-to-buy- votes   rural liquidity, chasing the usual goods and services, made more expensive by rising fuel, commodity and raw material prices, much of it imported.

Food inflation too, is topping 20% in urban areas at the retail level, and even wholesale price indices compiled by the Government, put it into the double digits. And the food bill accounts for 50% of many household expenditures, or even more in the case of the poor.

Government statistics ironically show rural food inflation, where the Government has propped up farm produce prices, at some 13% too. This food inflation, and general price rise of everything else, is devaluing our currency, in tandem with massive uncontrolled borrowing, as the Government hurtles towards a debt trap.

None of this welfare spending is productive in strictly economic terms, though welfarism has always justified itself in terms of alleviating poverty and human misery. But well-intentioned as this might be, it always ends up, doing the opposite, because the laws of economics do not condone a free lunch, and charges for it with compound interest.

Most people agree, for example, that Mr.Rajiv Gandhi was being wildly optimistic all those years ago when he said some 15% of welfare money actually reaches the intended recipients. Things haven’t got any better, to put it mildly.

This is partly due to corruption, and is partly a consequence of lazy targeting of the truly needy. The Government seeks to rectify this now via initiatives like the Aadhar Card and direct cash transfers. Let us see how this fares, but it is just so much charity, and ultimately unsustainable economically.
And more so in a country with huge absolute numbers, and an economy no bigger than about a trillion US dollars officially.

Welfarism works up to a point in countries with tiny populations, such as Norway and Kuwait, with huge resources per capita. It does not work in socialist France particularly, and did, only partially in Hugo Chavez’s Venezuela, fuelled by the petroleum wealth. And it has failed completely all over the Communist world.

But the growth in Gujarat, based on investment in productive enterprises, is solid; with over 10% GDP growth per annum, and over 10% unprecedented growth in agriculture. A set of figures impressive by any standards, especially since the base figures of the year before were not insubstantial in real terms either.
Contrast this with Bihar, where Mr. Nitish Kumar’s Government also claimed an 11% growth in GDP over the year before, but there the base figures are abysmal for a state with the size and natural resources of  Bihar. 

Statistics, we can see, can be made to dance any which way, but the picture on the ground must match.

All development- based growth is welcome though, because it makes a real difference, and applied at a national level, could catapult us forward. The economics of development is what will put “India First”, and carry all castes and communities with it.

(781 words)
March 10th, 2013
Gautam Mukherjee