!-- Begin Web-Stat code 2.0 http -->

Monday, April 8, 2013

Cromwellian Purity of Purpose:From Jassuben's Pizza to Induben Khakrawala


Cromwellian Purity of Purpose: From Jassuben’s Pizza to Induben Khakrawala

 At Mr. Narendra Modi’s address under the auspices of FICCI Women’s FLO organisation, in New Delhi’s capacious Le Meridien Hotel, the excitement was palpable.

Modi once again demonstrated his Cromwellian passion to improve the fortunes of “Bharat Mata” and equivalent purity of purpose. Oliver Cromwell, of course, was the earnest politician that substantially ended the era of absolute monarchy in Britain.

In the process, Mr. Modi was mellow and relaxed in his delivery today to a hall full of mostly women from the elite classes. But, quietly though it begins, Narendra Modi may be well on his way to striking a telling blow against the politics of dynasty and unquestionable entitlement.

 Modi’s politics of development and concrete achievements naturally outclasses the politics of unaccountability, privilege an d vague intention, bolstered at all times with cringe-worthy sycophancy. Even the desperate scare-mongering is wearing thin. The increasing number of Modi’s votaries packing the hall, in the studios, and in the interactive social media, have clearly moved on.
 
With his flair for extending the Gujarat analogy in all seasons, Mr. Modi did not disappoint in the context of women’s empowerment .  He pointedly avoided the laudatory achievements of big business in Gujarat on this occasion. Instead, he concentrated on example after example of successful grass- roots entrepreneurship by women, with the state playing facilitator in some instances.

Modi spoke entertainingly of the entrepreneurship of Jassuben’s Pizza and Induben’s Khakra in a modified version of Rahul Gandhi’s folksy approach. But there was more than sentimentality to drive home his points. He spoke of tribal women growing flowers marketed in Mumbai, and those who did likewise with cashews and almonds.

Mr. Modi cited many instances of female empowerment assisted by his Government in Gujarat, including the waiver of stamp duty for property registered in the name of women.

He asserted a staunch commitment to gender equality and decried the incidence of female foeticide all over the country that is creating a demographic imbalance. Mr.Modi has, and wants to constantly keep promoting, women’s participation in decision making.

Modi asserted that 50% or thereabouts of the population consisting of women needs to be brought into the political and economic discourse on an equal footing with men. And that given a chance, women often out- performed men in every field, some of them quite unusual in nature. He mentioned female tour guides in the Gir Forest  admiringly.

Mr. Modi felt, in answer to a question, that it was important to promote tourism to help the demand for handicrafts which are commonly manufactured by women.  

In his speech, he spoke of how the child widow Ganga Ma introduced the Charkha to the Mahatma which went on to be such a potent symbol of the freedom movement.

Most News Channels gave the address a build-up of talking head discussions for over an hour from 10.a.m. today, before the event was covered live, beginning shortly after 11.30 a.m.

At 1.15 pm, when Mr. Modi finished answering the last question at the function, the talking heads got to work again, analysing his pronouncements in acute detail.

“ The Modi Show”, as one channel called it, is clearly on the road. Next stop, a Chamber of Commerce in Kolkata tomorrow. And then back to core constituency Gujarat to celebrate Navratra.

(547 words)
8th April 2013
Gautam Mukherjee

Thursday, April 4, 2013

Coping with our millions




Coping with our millions

The Economist thinks India could do with 20 or 30 more states to take administrative care of a projected population of 1.6 billion by 2050. The theory being that smaller states will be better administered and run for the benefit of its people.

 The last round of new states were all created during BJP- led NDA rule, over nine years ago, the last time bold decisions were taken in  Government, inclusive of India going overtly nuclear. There were many other visionary moves made then, amongst them the hugely beneficial Golden Quadrilateral roads project .

The UPA, by way of contrast, in its two consecutive terms in power has effectively ruined the economy. On the plus side, it has managed to sign the Civil Nuclear Deal, and has passed FDI in single and multi-brand retail. And these too are being implemented at a snail’s pace.

Meanwhile,  Uttarakhand has  prospered, relatively speaking, since being hived off Uttar Pradesh. Chattisgarh too has done much better since being carved out of Madhya Pradesh. In a rarity since Independence, Chattisgarh, which suffers from a virulent Maoist menace in some of its districts, has nevertheless created a brand new capital at New or Naya Raipur.

Jharkhand, in terminal political flux since birth, has not fared that well, despite being very rich in natural resources. But the “rump” Bihar, is starting to revive, even though it is seeking “special” status from the Centre. The Economist was essentially writing in the context of the persistent agitation for a separate Telengana, the demand for which tends to hot up around election time.

Earlier, then Chief Minister Mayawati of Uttar Pradesh had suggested the quartering of the state for better governance, but the notion has since faded from public notice. And a long time ago, grass roots empowerment at the Panchayat level was mooted by former Prime Minister Rajiv Gandhi. That too has not made much progress over the years. The only fitful votary of Panchayati Raj these days is maverick Congressman Mr. Mani Shankar Iyer.

And Mr. Rahul Gandhi did mention the need to bring in the Pradhans into the political system because 4000 elected MLAs and 700 MPs were disconnected from the people. He did this in his maiden address to the CII on April 4th, 2013.

He spoke admiringly of the voting in the primary system in the US election process as well. And yes, if this can be implemented before this country sinks further into the mire, it might indeed prove beneficial. However, Rahul Gandhi is not very good at implementing his vision, and he is ignoring the nuts and bolts role played by various caucuses and interest groups even in the US.

But will smaller sizing of everything not put up costs? Ditto including the third and fourth tier and who knows whom else into the politico/governance machinery?

Will it not replicate hundreds of  administrative units all busy living off the sarkari gravy train?

Looking at the gargantuan and prohibitively expensive size of state and central Governments with its ancillaries and adjuncts, the answer does not seem encouraging. But some things could indeed get better.

At the city and municipal level, it is now revealed, Delhi is collecting more property taxes since the trifurcation of the MCD. And the number of property tax payers has also risen. The NDMC too has reached an all-time high in tax collection in 2012-13, up some 33%.

Hopefully, all this benefit to the municipal coffers will translate into better civic facilities, particularly greater cleanliness, efficient garbage collection, recycling, and/or its safe disposal, more parking lots including the modern multi-storied kind, rather than rough and ready fields commandeered to the purpose.  

In the case of Delhi there are of course, overlaps between the state, the municipalities and the centre, and so it is difficult to know and appreciate just what comes under which authority.

But building more municipal organisations should not result in just a larger number of municipal employees doing as little as possible for their monthly salaries.

While the efficacy of smaller administrative units both at state and municipal level, localised, and manned by people who live in them, should, in theory, provide better results, we have to wait and see what happens, particularly after the first flush.

The key seems to be in the ability to raise and deploy resources on its own instead of waiting on a central or superior authority elsewhere to allocate them. Plus, of course, a natural focus on the needs of the state now rendered more homogenous because of its regional identity. And the untangling of the multiple layers of decision- making, from the districts and blocks all the way up to the state level and on to the centre.

The  proof of the pudding  will have to be when the devolution and smaller unit structures actually spend most of the money they generate on the state, city, municipality, districts, blocks and panchayats. And not on themselves.

But government anywhere is not very good at being lean or productive. So smaller states , municipalities etc. or not, the key to long term benefit is in  having a bias towards shrinking government size to its essentials, and handing over all peripheral functions to the private sector.

This is precisely the Narendra Modi style of governance and it has worked well so far only in Gujarat.

The private sector works to market principles, and this, of course, may not suit people used to  doles, hand-outs and subsidies. It also means the downsizing of the gravy train mentality, both in government and amongst the people. 

Otherwise smaller units could mean an opportunity to secure a position because there are more of them made available.

And the same old corruption brought closer to home.

(958 words)
April 4th, 2013
Gautam Mukherjee

I have lost it...One Sec


“I have lost it…One Sec”

There is something disconcertingly childish about the 42 year old Mr. Rahul Gandhi. This wouldn’t be worrisome if he was a visiting lecturer from a minor Leftist college. Mr. Gandhi just does not have the heft of a full professor either way.

But this man is aspiring to become the prime minister of India, if all the buzz from his party and the media is to be believed, and he does admit India is “complex”. Unfortunately, there wasn’t one word he uttered that was the remotest bit practical throughout his speech and the reluctantly put Q&A that followed.

Mr. Gandhi dabbled self-consciously with broad- brush thematics, full of tired platitudes and mawkish sentiment. He stumbled through his prepared speech after a fashion. There were no solutions offered.
The biggest single idea stated was that the energy of the people needs to be unleashed. Yes, and infrastructure needs to be constructed. Yes, and everyone needs to be empowered.

It was reminiscent of a lecturer who would have been more comfortable teaching tiny tots at primary school. Analysts who spoke after the performance, even sympathetic ones, were left groping to describe it, and rate it within the context of Mr. Gandhi’s thoughts on Business and Industry.

The captains of said business and industry who were listening to him along with a contingent of senior bureaucrats and officials could barely raise weak applause two or three times during the hour. They did clap more enthusiastically at his assumed modesty, but the undertone was one of confused despair.

This man, the assemblage could see, had no answers for them. Everything that he talked of was on the never-never, with an infinity focus. Urgency and time frames were conspicuous by their absence.

Rahul Gandhi raised a few desultory issues in the most abstract terms leaving his audience quite foxed. He rambled on for over an hour, crossing and re-crossing the same ground with a disconnected, halting, anecdotal, rhetorical froth.

Yes, Rahul Gandhi clearly stated the Congress line on inclusiveness. He spoke of harmony. But he took absolutely no responsibility for the dismal showing of the UPA over the last nine plus years. Yet, Mr. Gandhi was careful to give himself a cop- out by declaring he wasn’t a “hard-nosed politician”. This even though his apprenticeship has taken him to the post of PM- in-waiting.

Or perhaps  one pole of the “diarchy- dual centres of power”  style of functioning without accountability, currently  being followed by the UPA.

Mr. Gandhi   said there is no “guy on a horse” who will come along and fix anything.  He believes it can’t be done by anyone, but this is better translated as he certainly can’t do it, and does not even want to try.

Rahul Gandhi was quite impassioned and sincere that he wants to give voice to the people of India. But he thinks the political system is clogged and cannot deliver. He thinks it is disconnected. He does not believe 4000 MLAs and 700 MPs can run this country effectively because they are not really representative. The Pradhans need to be brought into the political system he said, without giving any clue as to how.

The weird thing about all that he said is that it is at complete variance with the reality of what his Party and the UPA Government practices.

Perhaps Mr. Gandhi sees himself as some kind of political philosopher and critic of the system including his own party and government.

He used various anecdotes and analogies in his by now typical style. He did not agree with JFK’s statement about a rising tide raising all boats by quipping the poor have no boats and the Government must build it for them.

He spoke fitfully of exponential growth as opposed to incremental growth, but did not seem to have much faith in his speech-written lines. Rahul Gandhi spoke of dreams and energy, of infrastructure development, roads, ports, electricity, partnership with business and industry. Speed.

Seeds of a world class system, training, skill development, making education relevant and his speech mascot, Girish the migrant carpenter, come to Mumbai on the Lokmanya Tilak Express from Gorakhpur in UP.

But please Mr. Gandhi where is the action on any of this from your Government in power? Your Government which is disconnected. And which you admit is corrupt.  

But never mind all that. Mr. Gandhi actually panicked when he got his papers mixed up during his time on the CII podium. He said on the mike,  “I have lost it…One Sec”.

To me this sums it all up in his own words.

(762 words)
April 4th, 2013
Gautam Mukherjee

Sunday, March 31, 2013

The Glue Without A Clue


The Glue Without A Clue

The bad news on the economic front keeps rolling out like a juggernaut and goes down the drain, as just so much waste. And alongside are some appraisals of Mrs. Sonia Gandhi’s 15 years at the head of the Congress Party, both from home and abroad.

Not one assessment, apart from the hagiographies from Congress courtiers and what the press call “stooges”, have anything particularly nice to say.

They talk of her peculiar exercise of supreme power without responsibility. They plainly say that Mrs. Gandhi is the most powerful person in India, and the prime minister is not.

In the end, the best achievement of the Congress President is that she provides the “glue” that keeps the Congress from splitting up into many self-important pieces. At least this is the consensus of the commentary.

But the fact is, the now 66 year old “High Command” rules both the Party and the Government on a de-facto basis. So much so, that 80 year old Prime Minister Manmohan Singh, divested of any real responsibility for his actions and pronouncements, has indicated he might be up for a third term beyond 2014, if the opportunity presents itself.  

But Mrs. Gandhi has already had quite an innings. From the famed “renunciation” of the prime ministership in 2004, to the recent upliftment of her son to the Vice Presidency of the Party, she has kept the primacy of the Gandhi family intact.

But over the last three years or so, there has been a huge imbalance between emphasis on expenditure and income. The expenditure is designed to procure votes from the poor for the Congress Party, using the machinery and money of the Government. This may not be right ethically, but it has been greatly, and irresponsibly, enhanced.

The cavalier attitude to the income of the Government though is so prominent, that that the entire emphasis of the Finance Ministry and the RBI has been to try and contain inflation rather than promote growth.  

First class economists and strategists have had to suspend judgement and toe the High Command’s line in this regard.

Mrs. Gandhi not only runs the Party in terms of every appointment, every “ticket”, every shuffle and sacking, all without accountability, but also dictates Government policy via the National Advisory Council she chairs.
And this means dictation to the prime minister and the cabinet with ideas developed by a band of ultra-leftists that constitute the NAC on a nominated basis.

And her son, Mr. Rahul Gandhi, an avowed believer  in  “meritocracy”, has recently indicated he will accept both the Prime Minister’s job and that of the Party President, as it is no longer a good idea to have two centres of power. His spokesperson Mr. Digvijay Singh has just played cat’s paw in this regard.

But then, as the outspoken Justice Katju, the maverick Chairman of the Press Council and former Supreme Court judge says, democracy has been imposed on a feudal society here, and has ended up, he implied, a bit of a farce. He says he does not vote personally because others vote their caste etc. just like so many “sheep”.

And hurrah, Rahul Gandhi, a man who has hardly ever addressed a press conference, plans to speak to the business classes at CII shortly. We will, at last, possibly hear his thoughts on business and industry. Let us hope they are serious thoughts though, because Mr. Gandhi does like to keep it  as simple as possible.

The first family of the UPA, including contributions to most songs from sister Priyanka and bro-in-law  Robert Vadra, has nevertheless ruled, in  the complete sense of the word, during the last nine plus years.
The “family” has even micro-managed many Government decisions, but always, like Polonius, from behind the arras, in a manner that subverts the very meaning of transparency and democracy.

It is a style of functioning that  gives illustration to Justice Katju’s meaning of feudal, even imperial, with an army of courtiers ready to jump on any criticism of this insult to the intent of the Indian Constitution.

Meanwhile back in “Dole Raj”, no facts are allowed to interfere with the roll-out. MGNREGA which has consumed Rs. 170,000 crores and counting since inception in 2009, is a mess; with wages paid to poor people accounting for only 20% of this sum. All the rest has gone to leakages, corruption and middle men.

We now  have the Food Bill and the Homestead Act waiting in the wings, with the former already passed by the rubber-stamp of a Cabinet. In Congress circles, it is accepted MGNREGA won the 2009 elections for UPA II, and so, these two new babies are expected to deliver a third consecutive term.

This country is being driven into becoming a bankrupt “banana republic” just as Vadra said; with high-spending welfare policies that refuse to worry about fiscal responsibility. The single minded zeal to achieve re-election is all.

This glue does not brook criticism. And the script says that the economy is about to get better, has bottomed out and will be back up to 8 or 9% per annum in growth within another couple of years.

The idea is to appear to spend plentifully on the poor, those vividly described “mango people”, and pocket the electoral payoff. If this fails to materialise, and things actually go from bad to worse in the next couple of years, then it is due to the incompetence of the successor Government.

There will be a tussle, in the coming days, between this welfare based socialist election campaign, and the development economics of the challenger from Gujarat.

May the good glue stick and the bad one come unstuck.

(945 words)
March 31st, 2013
Gautam Mukherjee

The Congress Scorched Earth Policy




The Congress Scorched Earth Policy

Watching the reckless way in which the UPA Government is increasing welfare expenditure while income falls like a stone; one has to wonder at the underlying strategy. After all, the Congress Party heading this ruling coalition, prides itself on understanding governance better than all others. It has had cumulative decades in power.

Right-wing economist Mr. Surjit Bhalla, wrote a scathing indictment, calling the UPA’s economic management “disastrous”. This was in a recent Op-Ed piece in the Indian Express, which he ends by saying that Mrs. Sonia Gandhi who runs not only the Party but de-facto, the Government as well, may have ended up killing off the 128 year old Congress with her rampant Welfarism/Socialism.

Meanwhile, the dreadful economic facts pouring out from every survey and analysis seem to bolster Mr. Bhalla’s prognosis. Business and Industry has slowed to a near standstill, inflation including food inflation is shooting up, investment has stopped, the stock market is sinking,  the fiscal deficit has rocketed up to an all-time high, FDI has dried up, domestic demand has fallen drastically, growth has halved, exports are languishing, the rupee has depreciated at least 20%.

More relentless bad news is projected by non-partisan observers both domestic and foreign. Everyone is horrified by the profligacy except the seniors in the Government who continue to assure the public all is well and going to get better.

But is there a method in this madness? The UPA is hoping that the huge populism of the Food Bill and the Homestead Bill on top of all the subsidies and welfare programmes running presently will bring back 2009.

Then, the corruption- ridden MGNREGA caper is supposed to have delivered victory to them. So what if it has cost the nation some Rs. 1,70,000 crores with more than half the amount, Bhalla estimates it to be about $14 billion, siphoned off? Besides, the programme is faltering, only a fifth of the total spent paid out to the recipient poor in wages. It is certainly not a great success on the ground. But did it give Mrs. Gandhi UPA II?

So there is an attempt to pull off an encore.  But if UPA is shown the door in 2014, the Congress led Government may want to ensure the economy will be so ruined, that the successor Government will not last either. This particularly because of the populist compulsions of coalition politics.  The successor Government will inherit empty coffers, huge indebtedness, promises to deliver on, and an all-round fiscal mess.

This is a classic scorched earth policy, generally employed by retreating armies on the march. It says, in electoral terms, if I don’t get back in, whoever does will rue the day!
The BJP led NDA, most likely to form the next Government, is going to face huge economic challenges. Fortunately for the NDA, they are in power in a number of key states.  This will stabilise the aftermath to some extent.

In 2014, the real electoral battle is between Socialism’s non-delivery and disastrous economic performance under the UPA; and Development Economics, with a glorious track record in Gujarat, being promoted by the NDA. If this is polarisation of economic approaches, then so be it, and high time too. The bleating about growth without jobs and inclusiveness is fraudulent beyond the rhetoric.

The current UPA allies are disillusioned by the step-motherly treatment meted out to them by the Congress Party and are looking for alternatives. If the NDA makes them comfortable they may well switch sides.
Some like SP’s Mulayam Singh Yadav are not averse to the BJP while hoping to form another Third Front, but will such a front have the numbers? But who can argue with the benefits that will accrue from big ticket development?

With the advent of Mr. Narendra Modi into the parliamentary board of the BJP, it may be time for the principal Opposition to draw in more allies into the NDA.

The Trinamool Congress may be ripe, and the BJD too. Both SP and BSP could join up in principle, but only one can in practice. Ditto the equation with the DMK and the AIDMK.  Since Mr. Modi enjoys a personal equation with Ms. Jayalalithaa, the AIDMK is more likely to sign on. State by state, Modi must reach out.

Divisive issues such as the Uniform Civil Code, the abolition of Article 370 in Kashmir, Hindutva, Mandir and other majoritarian grandstanding,  needs to be replaced by Mr. Modi’s development plank converted into a battering ram. Development needs to be targeted and applied like a balm in minority heavy areas and elsewhere alike.

The Congress loves to call Mr. Modi a polarising figure. But the fact is, Gujarat’s growth has been most inclusive and more productive than in other places. This is beginning to be acknowledged by key Muslim groups in the state who are coming out in open support of Moditva.

Big, medium and small Business and Industry are solidly behind Mr. Modi. And the BJP have recently won even municipal elections in Muslim majority areas.

There is absolutely no truth in the kind of paranoid scare-mongering being promoted by the Congress in order to cling to yesterday. And Law and Order under the UPA has sunk to an all-time low while terrorism is running riot.

Some people are questioning the basic patriotism and integrity of various senior functionaries of the Congress Party and Government. The open looting that has replaced governance in a procession of scams ranging from the thievery allowed during the CWG, the multiple defence scams, the 2G Scam, the food grains scam, the water scam, the coal scam, etc. make you wonder whom this Government is actually serving? What happens to the High Command when this daylight robbery is going on?

The UPA’s nearly ten years in power finds both the country and the UPA in near ruin. How it came to this pass with supposedly competent and experienced people in the Government is quite a mystery.
The Congress Party speaks proudly of its “glue”, in the form of the inviolate and Peronistic High Command, while sneering at the BJP’s democratic  “infighting”. It only goes to show what happens when the glue itself is clueless.

Put charitably, the Congress Party is practicing the politics of nostalgia. It is hankering after a jingoistic and anachronistic throw- back to its glory days of single party near- dictatorship with appalling Soviet style Socialism.

It is now the job of today’s electorate to wake up to present-day reality, of aspirations, of modernity, of prosperity and growth, and sweep away the tired propagandists of empty promises and routine betrayal.  

(1,099 words)
March 31st, 2013
Gautam Mukherjee

Thursday, March 28, 2013

And The Walls Fall Down




And the Walls Fall Down

The last bastion is under attack. The big white hope of economic resurrection, that phoenix to rise from the ashes, is India’s domestic engine of growth.

It has always been the idea of robust and reliable Demand that is the best thing about the “India Story”. And this demand projection is overwhelmingly domestic.

Till now, domestic demand has grown, generally in double digit percentages year- on- year, varying from sector to sector. It has surged, fuelled by evident and pent up demand, the latter driven by earlier cumulative supply deprivation.

This phenomenon is what has made us attractive to every peddler of goods and services from Tipperary to Timbuktu, hiding at the same time, a thousand embedded and endemic sins of inefficiency and delay in the Indian way.

Demand in the Indian economy has been routinely reckoned to be robust for several decades to come, because we are woefully short of infrastructure and modern amenities. However, goods and services have started meeting expectations. Still, we are far away from the prerequisites of a developed nation.
Exports account for just 25% of GDP in round figures. This includes IT at nearly 8%; while merchandise exports are 17.7% within this mix.

There is only modest market share growth in IT exports, about 9%, and value addition too, but profit is declining from a heady 25% to 30% before 2008 to about 10% to 12% now.

Despite this, the logic is impeccable. India has a billion point two in population. India has a 60% population between the ages of 15 and 35. China is ageing. Europe is both broke and geriatric, and accounts for 300 million souls with a negative birth rate and at least 30 million unemployed.

America can, and by default is, boosting numbers and vitality with Hispanic immigration. Obama used this shrewdly in both his election victories, because the demographics, and with it, the attitudes are changing very substantially.

South America and Africa are, as yet, beautiful works in progress. The Asia-Pacific is largely developed and now coming relentlessly under the shadow of Chinese domination.

But BRICS is faltering too, Brazil, Russia and South Africa have growth rates in the 2% to 3% band, India is between 4% and 5%, and China too is not going to see double digits very soon either.

But things are likely to get worse for us. Home grown ratings agency CRISIL RESEARCH says Indian demand is to slow even more sharply.

India Inc. Revenue growth will decelerate to 7.5% in the fourth quarter of this financial year, from 17.5% for the corresponding g Q4 last year.

CRISIL reviewed 28 sectors of the economy, excluding banks and oil and gas, and this is the projection.  Everything that is investment-linked will decline further. So capital goods, construction, vehicles, tyres, auto components, steel, are all falling.

And this is partly happening because of the shameful mismanagement of the economy. CRISIL says administrative delays, high cost of money, huge inflation are all causatives.

Information Technology is down, but it is better off than manufacturing. So is Telecom, and Entertainment, on the back of greater digitisation and its cost savings. But no one’s balance sheet has much of a wow factor to it today.

Unless the Government revives investor sentiment with rapid developments both in policy and on the ground, this scenario is going to get worse. We need massive investment now. Otherwise, some sectors will descend into negative growth territory.

The choking of growth, after all, was a deliberate policy carried out to contain inflation. The effort has failed in its objective but has strangulated growth alright!

Business confidence going forward is lower than it has been for the last three years according to the NCAER Survey. And shareholder returns have, in any case, been declining ever since 2008-09 according to a Financial Express Survey.

There is very little the Government seems   to be doing to arrest this terminal decline despite the Prime Minister’s wish to revive “animal spirits”. Of course, no sooner does Mr. Manmohan Singh declare something, one of his ministers or the High Command decides to contradict him.

Consistency of policy therefore be damned in the UPA, with its dual centres of power. We are not likely to revive anything in the months left to this weakened Government, and ditto if UPA is returned to power.  
Across the aisle, if Mr. Narendra Modi is brought in to lead, his expressed strong support for business and industry and economic growth will certainly deliver the goods.

Let us hope the BJP, its affiliates and allies, plus the electorate, realises it, and does what it takes to raise him to the Prime Minister’s post.

(773 words)
March 28th, 2013
Gautam Mukherjee

Saturday, March 23, 2013

Messy Business



Messy Business

The Prime Minister, the President, Indian Union Ministers and junior ones, senior bureaucrats, trade body heads, even captains of business and industry who are shanghaied into delegations, go abroad routinely, and expensively, to tout the India story. Brand equity tends to beggar comparison, but advertisements do not a reality make!

So the results are meagre, because there is little done to fix the back- office functioning of a country that is immensely difficult to work in. Not only that, we take delight in taking ideological, bureaucratic, even uncaring anti-business policy positions, eroding the wealth of our companies, while the Government exudes supreme unconcern.

Take for example the fact that mid-cap stocks, that represent the bulk of Indian  business and industry numerically, all clocking in at between $ 2 to 10 billion US in market capitalisation, have lost 90% of their stock value  per a recent news report; with little hope of recovery in a tight bear market.
They have effectively been reduced to small- caps, and our publicly held financial assets economy has therefore shrunk. Is SEBI, the RBI, the Finance Ministry, The Planning Commission, The Ministry of Commerce, any arm or leg of Government, at State or Central level, doing anything about it? Have they even noticed?

Consider also that Large-caps, meaning those with a market capitalisation of between $10 to $200 billion are really not all that numerous in a $1 trillion sized official economy.  So the depth of the market is decimated and sequestered yet again with no policy reaction whatsoever.

Who is responsible for this precipitous decline? Is it their own shabby entrepreneurship? Or is it a very challenging macro environment with high interest rates, difficult liquidity, high commodity prices, inflexible labour laws, massive taxation, utilities both expensive and inadequate, high transportation costs, bad infrastructure, etc. etc.

If Japan took the world by storm once, as did Taiwan, and now as China is, heading towards becoming the No.1 economy according to OECD, they did not do it without tremendous Government support. It was a veritable partnership.

It is not as if we Indians cannot do it. Narendra Modi’s Gujarat is an example of our own ingenuity and entrepreneurship, with the State helping business and industry, including agriculture and agro-industry, to flourish and grow.  

That is why Mr. Modi is lauded by top business and industry leaders all over the country. But oddly, at the Centre, there is a concerted effort to debunk the achievements of the Government of Gujarat and some feeble attempts to claim credit for Modi’s achievements by saying he is harvesting what the earlier Congress Governments had sown, absurd as this sounds.

The fact that such progress has not been replicated anywhere else, is enviously glossed over. There are small gains which are spun out, minute policy adjustments are advertised as further reform, but the net results have been moribund and inadequate.

Recently, the Economic Affairs Secretary,  Mr.  Arvind  Mayaram went to Washington to be told by US investors that doing business in India was “messy”.

This despite India’s attempt to show- case its new found  Reforms zeal. Mr. Mayaram tried hard to convince his audience of the Government’s commitment to spurring growth and investment, cutting subsidies and the deficit, the whole nine yards of intent. But the US investors were not convinced.

It is very difficult for India to be taken seriously by any but the very brave and determined. Mr. Mayaram talked of $ 20 billion in infrastructure investment approvals, but we know as Indians, that this need not mean very much on the ground. At best, a fraction of a fraction of this investment will see the light of day in the projected time framework. 

The lack of consistency in Government policy is probably the most damning macro problem.  And the readiness to mislead and misrepresent is almost dishonest.

In the recent budget the Finance Minister P.Chidambaram probably over- estimated income, under- estimated expenditure, over- optimised the effects of welfare, and left all the whopper stuff, as in The Food Act and the Homestead Act, in the “coming soon” trailer.

Economists that favour market economics, such as Mr. Surjit Bhalla, routinely pour scorn on Government computations, statistics, assumptions, and indeed, the policy.

We will, most probably, have to wait for the outcome of the next general election for any real change.
If the right- of- centre Mr. Narendra Modi leads the next Government, expect progress and real growth.

If not, more of the same but with bells on; because then it will be seen as a vindication of the Leftist doctrine being pushed currently as if the life of the UPA depended on it.

(773 words)
March 23rd, 2013
Gautam Mukherjee