!-- Begin Web-Stat code 2.0 http -->

Wednesday, March 5, 2014

Sahara's Face Blackened


Sahara’s Face Blackened

The proverbial long-arm of the law appears to have caught up with parabanking real estate mogul Subrata Roy Sahara and his diversified conglomerate. The Supreme Court, via a vehement two judge bench, heard his pleas for several hours, unmoved.  At length, it denied and disallowed any flexibility in the repayment of some Rs. 24,000 crores ‘illegally’ raised from ‘millions’ of alleged investors.

In an unusual show of exasperation, rigidity, harshness, even anger, the honourable and learned judges said Roy had been consistently lying to the apex court for one and a half years while mocking the judiciary by submitting false affidavits. It refused to believe Roy’s contention that he had in fact paid back most of the investors already, mostly in cash, as some  were often simple folk like rickshaw pullers, who are not likely to acknowledge communications from SEBI as to whether they had been paid. And people at that level often had little by way of a fixed address but were in touch with one or the other of Sahara’s army of 12 lakh staff.

It must be remembered, for context, if nothing else, that the Sahara Group, which told the Supreme  Court that it had paid back Rs. 137 lakh crore to its investors over its nearly four decades in operation, started with an investment of Rs. 2,000/-, and a scooter, in Gorakhpur, Uttar Pradesh, way back in 1978. Roy took over a near defunct chit-fund company called Sahara and remodelled it after Peerless style residuary non-banking companies that accept deposits in tiny amounts.

Roy offered to send hundreds of Sahara staff to help SEBI verify the truck-loads of repayment documentation submitted. Again, this too cut no ice with the highest court in the land, which suggested that perhaps many of the investors were fictitious. It ordered Roy and two of his directors into judicial custody in Tihar Jail in New Delhi till March 11th  , or sooner, if an acceptable method was found on how the money was going to be repaid by ‘cheque or draft’. The visceral implication is that the Sahara Group is a huge black money cum laundering operation. It is true enough that rumours have long had it that there is a lot of politician, bureaucrat and film star money that circulates and rotates in the coffers of the Sahara Group. But, this run in with the law at the level of the apex court is an unprecedented first in 37 years.

Still, there is nearly Rs. 5,600 crores of the 24,000 crores in liquid form already with SEBI of which it has disbursed only a meagre Rs 1 crore to some investors. At the core of this case seems to be a crackdown on the Sahara Group and its extensive dealings in cash at the grassroots level, and on the fringes of the regulatory environment. SEBI, since its powers were enhanced, has had scant success with any of its investigations so far, but this time, thanks to the might of the Supreme Court joined to itself, it seems to be making its mark.      

Roy promised to furnish an irrevocable bank guarantee for the entire Rs. 24,000 crores and promised to pay back all investors still not reimbursed by selling real estate assets. But alas, even this was not accepted by the august judges of the Supreme Court who asked for a better and more reliable scheme. What is crystal clear is that Roy has lost all credibility with both SEBI and the Supreme Court, and would be best advised to comply with their wishes and put this behind him and the Sahara Group. There is, after all, no appeal to anyone except God beyond the apex court! Until a final verdict, one can’t even ask for a review!

While the Supreme Court decisions cannot be questioned, a casual observer may wonder how liquor baron Vijay Mallya suffered no such personal humiliation and harsh stricture for the collapse of Kingfisher Airlines, with massive unpaid debts, thousands of unpaid employees, huge dues to the Government etc.. He is even personally liable for some of the Airlines’ debts. But, of course, every case is different, and the wheels of justice may just have not got around to the point of reckoning as yet for the King of Good Times.

And then there’s Capt. Gopinath from whom Mallya bought his low-cost airline Air Decccan and took over its debt, before that too went the way of the premium brand Kingfisher.  Sahara was better at selling off its airline before it blew too big a hole in its finances. But all of this has been regarded by the Government, the regulatory authorities and the judiciary in a reasonably dispassionate manner. It is only in this instance, albeit after giving Sahara a year and a half to comply with its strictures already that the boom has been lowered. 

Still let us remember that the Government itself routinely wastes tens of thousands of crores in failed ventures and badly structured deals. The CAG may complain but nothing happens by way of accountability for all the public money. Everyone goes scot-free. But when it came to Subrata Roy Sahara the court may have decided to set new precedents for the future. 

(872 words)
March 5th, 2014

Gautam Mukherjee

Tuesday, March 4, 2014

Rajniti Nahi Kajniti




Rajniti Nahi Kajniti

This is a strange time. I almost feel like quoting the first lines of A Tale Of Two Cities, but am able to restrain the self-indulgence.  A schizophrenic Congress is synonymous with corruption; scams are coming out of its darkness like well-fed maggots, for whom this has been a very productive season indeed. But the top Congress people are probably taking their tranquilizers in order to keep their cool and focus. They abuse Modi and BJP with the same tired lines, praise proxy voodoo doll Kejriwal, keep quiet about all the other parties,  talk feelingly about the poor, democratic values ( while it runs a dynastic rule), and inclusiveness, (while it sees much less than there is to see in Muzaffarnagar for example).

The hoardings and TV shorts around the country with trite slogans like Rajniti Nahi Kajniti tells you how the advertising industry will try and service your illusion every time. But they are only doing their jobs.

The latest attempt at daylight robbery, allegedly involving an unrepentant Robert Vadra acting for DLF Ltd. once again, is for blocks of flats a kilometre away, and overlooking the Mughal Gardens at Rashtrapati Bhavan. The 22 acre property is worth about 10,000 crores in the open market, but needs to be absorbed into the President’s Estate at any nominal cost, with a smart little ordinance to get all the greed out of the way. This particularly since there is a helipad mooted and in the offing for the use of the President and others.

Meanwhile, owner DLF has managed that root of all manna in the property game, the CLU (Change of land use), for the expenditure of a few crores, between  2010 and 2012, and obtained plan sanctions too. There is a chilling account of a proposed 39 metre wall to block a view of the President’s Estate. This, to get over security objections,  presumably the better to site snipers away from the popular gaze!

The PM’s Office saw nothing wrong in this bizarre proposal. The Intelligence Bureau ditto. The Urban Development Ministry, overseen by veteran businessman cum politician Kamal Nath  passed the proposal up to 4 storeys, with a review clause to take it up to 8!

It was the President’s Secretariat that had to cry enough, since no one else is looking out for it. And DLF is as yet feigning innocence, and there is nary a peep from Vadra. Why was this 22 acre development pending fire ever since DLF bought it, dairy land, over from Keventer’s Successors in 1992? Patience, it must be noted, goes with the acquisition of great wealth.

DLF knew they had a wonderful piece of real estate and must have been waiting for a powerful agent that could make the Government do whatever it wanted. The security of the President, the Cabinet, visiting dignitaries etc. perambulating on the Rashtrapati Bhavan lawns, be damned. DLF says the hoohah is exaggerated and there are several other tall building in the area, and says the Samrat Hotel overlooks the PM’s residence. The idea being to suggest if it is good enough for the PM then why not the President and his guests?

For a commercial company to care only about its investment and returns is appropriate. But how does a Central Government, in all its oversight and institutions, blithely fall in line? And look at the timing. It is like a final grab at the buffet table despite pockets bulging; unless we are going to be treated to even more revelations in the remaining days.

Perhaps it has been cynically calculated, that all the other noise, on the Rolls Royce engine supply to HAL and kickbacks of Rs. 500 crores paid, The Westland Helicopter cancelled contract in which Italy is holding over a 1000 crores of the tax payers money, the other pending scams without number, including the telecom and mining ones, involving tens of thousands of crores, will swamp this item. Everything is awaiting judicial attention, and this will obscure, overwhelm and hide this little gift to DLF. Besides, the electioneering is intensifying to full pitch at present, and there is no room on any contender’s side to allow distractions.

And Kejriwal, who ironically came to prominence as an anti-corruption crusader, is very comfortable sitting in the lap of Congress and talking communalism as his new area of focus. Some reports say corruption and all the other ills he promised to banish actually got worse during his 49 days in office. That in itself is not surprising. Superman could not have done all that he promised in such a short time. It is his mistaking his lowly jhadoo as a magic wand a la Harry Potter that caused the mess. And it is threatening to do more of the same because he won’t leave off with his reckless rabble-rousing.

His attack on Reliance is also reportedly at the behest of Congress. Mukesh Ambani has drawn closer to Modi and the BJP, and Congress, famous for its vindictiveness, wants revenge. Kejriwal’s pro-Muslim avatar is not washing nationally, but in Delhi, the people, according to a new poll, seem to want the AAP with a 46% projected vote share and an implied thumping majority.  But like the Delhi middle class and the Three-wheeler workers,   more people may walk away from the firebrand that hobnobs with Maoists and fails to deliver. The BJP State Unit, now under the clean and well-liked Harsh Vardhan, needs to urgently strategise.

Why has UPA’s 10 years been so marred by corruption? One, both general elections in 2004 and 2009 were unexpected wins. But now, why is it clear that Congress has lost interest in growing the economy despite its pronouncements? Why does every ministry, bureaucrat, MP and MLA under the umbrella of the UPA feel free to make money now with no fear of retribution? Is it because it has become common knowledge that the Congress High Command cannot deliver the votes anymore. It is sitting on a precarious and weakened perch, hoping massive welfarism and letting all and sundry make hay while the sun shines will see it through. 

Congress certainly believes so, and considers other, equally corrupt parties, are more comfortable with its methods. And there are some powerful foreign powers, including America, who would like that very much. A weak, corrupt, malleable, insecure India can be used very well. Many major powers are not looking forward to both China and India becoming strong and difficult to manage. China is tough enough to tackle. Russia too is not for turning. A weak India can well suit the global power play.

(1,101 words)
March 4th, 2014

Gautam Mukherjee

Friday, February 28, 2014

The Subrata Roy Sahara Arrest Seems Like Overkill



The Subrata Roy Sahara Arrest Seems Like Overkill

Part of the Sahara imbroglio can be attributed to Stock Market regulator SEBI wanting to try out its newly installed teeth and claws. SEBI has turned the confrontation into a test case because it wants to have massive oversight, along with punitive and search and seizure powers like the American US SEC. And the Sahara Group, with its flamboyant Chairman, presents a juicy target. SEBI has picked on a Sahara Group debenture issue to private investors, millions of them, as is the wont of parabanking giants like Sahara and Peerless; via a couple of unlisted companies, as listed companies were  disallowed to do this kind of fund-raising now.

The amount in question is some Rs. 24,000 crores, typically made up of millions of small deposits. SEBI, on its part, is citing a law that if the depositors number more than 50, it automatically becomes a public raising of funds, and comes under its purview.  SEBI therefore instructed Sahara to return the funds to the investors as they had been raised ‘illegally’. Sahara, ostensibly has complied in the main. SEBI however is not convinced. In the balance, should this lead to a weakening of the Sahara Group, are the jobs of over a million employees and many millions of investors.

This despite SEBI having been sent 17 truck-loads of papers that allegedly prove Sahara has paid back most of its investors. SEBI has reportedly not ploughed through this ‘proof’ as yet, even as several more truck-loads of material await its scrutiny in a Mumbai godown. Instead, SEBI has got the Court to order Sahara to deposit Rs. 24,000 crores either in cash or by way of suitable and unencumbered property documents with it, in case the evidence does not check out. It is a fact that Sahara is struggling to do all this in cash-strapped circumstances presently, but there is nothing to suggest a  deeper malaise.
  
Sahara on its part has deposited some 5,206 crores claiming, at the time, that the net outstanding was about Rs. 5,120 crores. Since then, more payouts have been made, and the net outstanding now is about Rs. 2,000 crores. The property documents, also submitted to SEBI are apparently not up to the requisite value of over Rs. 20,000 crores, but since most of the money has allegedly been paid back, events may have overtaken this requirement. But not, it seems, SEBI scepticism.

The RBI has also been fretting over regulation of parabanking, and has curtailed much of Sahara’s room to manoeuvre over the years, and there is also the rumoured Congress high command antipathy towards the Group. The close relations that the Sahara Group has long enjoyed with Samajwadi Party and the father and son duo of Mulayam Singh Yadav and Akhilesh also seems now to be missing in action.

Sahara is no longer as cash-rich as it used to be, partially because of some large overseas hotel purchases, a downturn in the real estate asset valuations and liquidity,and the regulatory killing off of most of its parabanking businesses. It has also suffered significant losses in some of  its diversified forays.

The Supreme Court’s insistence on a personal appearance of corporate big-wig Subroto Roy Sahara, followed by a non-bailable arrest warrant, has now coalesced and focussed attention on the case. It is also why Subrata Roy Sahara is in a forest rest house near Lucknow under police custody till 2 pm on March 4th when the bench of the Supreme Court will see and hear him in New Delhi.

If indeed only some Rs. 2,000 crores remains to be paid out, it possibly will resolve quite quickly. The Honourable Supreme Court justices are annoyed at Subrata Roy dragging his feet when summoned, though the latter claims it is because his 92 year old mother is seriously ill. It may also be important to bring this case to a business-like conclusion in short order to send out a signal that India is not in the way of harassing its eminent and accomplished corporate brass. If the idea is to make clear that no one is above the law, surely there is also a need to calibrate judicial wisdom and outreach according to the nature and gravity of the legal infraction. Top lawyers Ram Jehmalani and Ravi Shankar Prasad who are representing Subrata Roy, did try and fail to get his arrest waived and the hearing advanced.

But looking forward now, they need to put this matter into judicial perspective before it does a lot of damage to the image of India at a time when we need to encourage business, industry, FDI and FII.  India’s GDP has meanwhile plummeted to 4.78% and this kind of high profile trial that involves the arrest of top corporates does not help matters.

(793 words)
March 1st, 2014

Gautam Mukherjeence ts new teeth and claws and the Supreme Court'

Modinomics Comes Closer



Modinomics Comes Closer

Narendra Modi is being keenly followed for his economic vision. Recently, in various fora, including traders, captains of industry and chartered accountants, he gave both the target audiences and the voting public a glimpse sometimes, a little more elaborate preview at others. While more detailed specifics will be spelled out in the BJP manifesto and in the Vision 2020 document to be released shortly. And, of course, in his ongoing speeches, and those of other NDA leaders, over the next 60 days. Modi made it clear however that he had a strong and inclusive development agenda.

He  also brought the old Mahatma Gandhi/Tata idea of ‘Trusteeship’ out of the closet for another turn in the sun, implying Government’s that claim to be doing the public a favour, are in effect being less than truthful. This, because they are essentially taking initiatives with the public’s money, while pretending to be bountiful.
The other macro point, undeniable in its authenticity, is NaMo’s assertion that as a Chief Minister of long standing, coming out to the national arena, he knows precisely where the shoe pinches for the State satraps. 

He has promised to empower the States and strengthen federalism. He is also showing a great responsiveness to economic suggestions from various quarters, be they that of the trader organisations, the chambers of commerce, think-tanks, intellectuals, captains of industry, media mavens etc. Modi has promised to simplify the thicket of complex laws that affect the businessman to promote ease of working and quickened inclusive growth.

And he asserted continuously that he would do everything not tackled in 60 years of Congress/UPA rule, give or take, in the 60 months of the next Government’s tenure. He expects India at 75, in round figures if somewhat beyond the next 60 months, to be renewed afresh into a ‘new country’. Modi’s is an exciting, bold and transformational message, and implies that the gradualism and incrementalisation of approach followed by the UPA with limited success, will be sharply overhauled to promote rapid growth and progress for all sections. Perhaps now, at last, India   will be set on the path of realising its true potential.

Modi says he wants to see GST implemented and sees it as a great unifier pan-India, but points out you cannot do so till the IT connectivities are put in place. He says the UPA has been lethargic over it, rather than the States, but then what’s new? He wants, most of all probably, to ramp up infrastructure spends as possibly the key growth driver.

HDFC’s Deepak Parekh, who seems to be on the same page, pointed out at a function under the auspices of the India Foundation, that infrastructure spending had been derailed over the last two years, and needed urgent attention from the new Government. Of the over $1 trillion projected in the 12th Plan period, 47% was meant to come from the private sector, but this  has certainly not been forthcoming, with two years of the plan period already elapsed. Parekh suggested corporatisation of the Railways, ramping up urban infrastructure, developing brand new cities and injection of massive FDI. We know China and Japan are waiting in the wings to bring in a lot of investment, and there are probably others, like Saudi Arabia and Iran, waiting to make their declarations soon. Notice our potential that our investors do not have to belong to the same camp. This is a lesson that should not be lost on the US and NATO and may be a philosophical gift from our idealistic non-alignment days. So Russia and the US are welcome, along with Germany and France and Australia too. 

Narendra Modi, as always, positioned himself as an ardent Reformist and an efficient administrator, emphasising that Governance was very important. This brings cheer and not a little wonder to all in an age of policy paralysis where all hopes have been long belied. With just a couple of months to go till the elections, and possibly a substantial economic renaissance.

Modi says we have almost fallen out of the BRICS  wall, Humpty-Dumpty like, and need to get back into the reckoning. Who can deny that this is true? But it is a practical streak amongst all the lofty intent that is the most reassuring about Modinomics. Modi wants to bring about 24x7 electricity around the country, including the little villages, and strong Internet connectivity. On the back of this intent, he exhorted small traders to develop virtual malls and not be afraid of technology or the big traders either.

Columnist Andy Mukherjee, writing in Business Standard, says he expects Modi to revive ‘credit growth’.  He joins commentator and free-marketeer Gurcharan Das and Siddharth Birla of FICCI in desiring more detail on Modinomics in the coming days.  Still, almost all observers and analysts expect optimism to return, and business and industry, rooting heavily for Modi, to start borrowing for modernisation and expansion again.

The dependence on populist coalition partners might queer the pitch a little, some reckon, but the stock markets and property markets are expected to revive. The numbers are anywhere upwards of 10 to 30%, according to the international rating agencies watching India, with more than the usual interest at this time.

 (869 words)
28th February 2014

Gautam Mukherjee

Tuesday, February 25, 2014

America Does Not Want A Strong India




America does not want a strong India

The rise of Narendra Modi and the prospect of a BJP/NDA Government at the Centre in a few months time is being viewed with trepidation, not only by extremist and inimical elements in Pakistan, but with little warmth by the US as well.  A more assertive India, when it is already much too independent for  America’s liking, is not seen to be particularly welcome.

President Obama, approaching the end of his second and final term in office, in 2016, has lost interest in the strategic relationship that his predecessor George W Bush initiated. The disappointment began when India decided not to buy its mega order of 126 off fighter jets from the US, and finally settled on the advanced but largely untried in combat Rafale jets from France instead. Obama thought his PR blitzkrieg during his visit to India had all but sewn up the order, one of the biggest single purchases of military hardware in the world in recent times.

After being miffed by the Indian action, he has more or less distanced his administration from India, and downgraded his expectations from the relationship. In addition, the present Secretary of State John Kerry is perceived to be more or less pro-Pakistan when compared to his predecessor Mrs Hillary Clinton.
 India is effectively strategically downgraded for the moment, and China’s constant provocations on our borders are also a reflection of the distance that is developing in the Indo-US bilateral relationship.

Meanwhile, much as Americana is the prevalent influence, and the economic and cultural yardstick here, the American strategic vision with regard to  India reflects an altogether colder reality. Americana reigns in large parts of the world, in an economically bonded and beholden EU, in much of the English-speaking world, and specifically amongst the young. America represents the good life; in freedom, dignity and plenitude, but always tending towards isolationism. But yet drawn into assuming its responsibilities as the world’s sole super power, oracle, and general arbiter. Despite this, it seems, of late, alas, America is no longer interested in being inclusive.

Hollywood movies, Apple smartphones, and American popular music and so on may be on the mind and at the finger-tips of most affluent people around the globe. And its ambassadors, McDonalds, KFC, the neighbourhood air-conditioned Mall, Starbucks, designer jeans, the wonder weaponry, the massive economic might even in its decline, are indeed all hugely aspirational in the emerging economies.

But, alongside this easy palatability, our embrace of Americana, our desire to emulate, is not felt or believed to be reciprocal. We in India must realise that we are neither viewed with such eager warmth, nor included in the American scheme of things in any deeper sense.  And the lack of movement on all fronts in the bilateral relationship underlines this.

Our outgoing Prime Minister Dr. Manmohan Singh, did try very hard. He wanted to change the India-US relationship from one of decades of ‘benign neglect’ on the part of the US, to a ‘strategic partnership’  full ofr vibrancy and movement.But, this was not to be. India is, for the moment, not to guard the Indian Ocean around its neighbourhood for the US. It is not going to be developed into any kind of counter balance to China.  Our exasperating non-alignment does not suit America’s John Wayne type sensibilities.

We are therefore assessed to be decent enough but not seen as a reliable ally. We do not have enough to offer the US if we routinely fail/ refuse to lay out a red carpet against every item of bilateral advantage. Even Dr. Manmohan Singh could not dare go that far, much to the chagrin of the Americans.

The Americans probably expected huge reparations in exchange for their leaning our way in the Civil Nuclear Deal. The nuclear pariah status did end thanks to US backing, but nothing substantial by way of implementation has followed in the wake of that breakthrough. Nor have we become an obvious American satellite as was anticipated, even demanded, by the US.

India keeps asking for bilateral reciprocity, as if we do not understand that we must know our place. And reciprocity cannot be demanded by the weaker from the stronger.And if the size of the Indian market is considered to be our ultimate leverage and lure; the Americans think they can access it anyway without conceding very much in return.  And so we find ourselves searching our own faces in the mirror and wondering why we find ourselves in political limbo.

That inclusive and inspiring, and vastly generous American dream of the founding fathers of nearly 250 years ago, ended long so.  It was set aside along with Ellis Island as a point of entry. When it was open, ships carrying impoverished Irishmen, Italians, English, Welsh and Scots, East Europeans, Jews, Germans Poles, Lithuanians, Lebanese, all coming from the ‘old world to the new’, across the Atlantic and other seas, to New York. And under the blazing gaze of the Statue of Liberty. Today Ellis Island basks in   its silent emptiness, no  more than a tourist attraction, and that kind of open-handedness and welcome ended well over a century ago.

That American dream changed with technology upgradation, and time. When ships gave way to planes, Time itself quickened, and America grew rich. And the socio-economic barriers started going up. America’s rulers have been steadily less forthcoming  as the 20th century advanced, and tightened immigration even more in the 21st. Most of the Indian diaspora in the US trace their migration to the 1960s and 1970s when professionals from the sub-continent were in demand. Today’s IT men, if they are not US citizens or Green Card Holders, are only tolerated on short-term visas, but are preferably  engaged to work offshore, or in India itself.

The American Black may well marvel at an African-American in the White House, but there is little that is necessarily pro-black about Obama in the conduct of his governance or policies.  

Perhaps this is because Obama is both White and Black at the same time. The point is however, no matter how it was all intended, huge inequalities do thrive in America. The top couple of per cent of the population own 98% of the wealth and resources. The lot of the wage-earning or unemployed underprivileged in the US has not been getting appreciably better since the Second World War!

And since the recent Wall Street Crash of 2008,  more suddenly impoverished people are much worse off. And despite some signs of revival now, the US economy will stay under pressure for at least the rest of this decade.  

(1,098 words)
January 21st, 2014

Gautam Mukherjee

New India Is An Exciting Overlay



New India Is An Exciting Overlay

Driving from New Delhi to Goa for the first time, some 2000 kilometres, I confirm and discover that there are four or six-lane expressways that enable consistent speeds of over a 100 km throughout. That is, for all expect the last bit, from naturally air-conditioned Belgaum to touristy Goa.

All of it, these stupendous roads, conceived of and initiated by former prime minister Atal Behari Vajpayee in his terms at the helm of the NDA, is now built and completed, an amazement to me in itself. It is not often when India completes, substantially and fulsomely, what it has begun.  

And these roads, will transform the connectivities in this country, if they have not already done so.  To drive along them involves the paying of scores of tolls, but adding up to no more than perhaps Rs. 3,000/-, a modest enough fraction of what one would pay in the EU or elsewhere, probably as much or more in Euro, for such a cross-country jaunt today.

Thank God once again for our robust numbers which help to keep the charges modest. But most of the roads are indeed as good as anything abroad, except for the fact that very few  eligible Indians drive across the country for pleasure, or indeed, business.  Most upwardly mobile middle class Indians are essentially noveau riche in attitude, and thus oblivious of many finer points that make for the nuanced life. In their thinking and values, it is preferable, as a status thing, to fly everywhere, and be driven, rather than drive, for the rest. The lure of the ‘open road’ as a metaphor for freedom and renewal is mostly an American thing and little comprehended here.

So these wonderful roads are almost exclusively the province of the pan- India travelling trucks, driven by hard working if prosaic illiterates, hauling all manner of cargo. And reasonably localised movements of motorcycles carrying entire families, commuters between obscure villages, tractors carrying sugarcane, and the like.

And those of the middle /entrepreneurial classes who swan around on these roads in their high performance modern cars, are served, along the new highways, by a  liberal sprouting  of KFC’s and McDonalds and  the home grown CafĂ© Coffee Days, interspersed with more desi fare, both vegetarian and non-vegetarian. I even spotted a Parsi Dhaba in the neighbourhood of Bharuch. The pizzas, burgers and food courts, the malls on the edge of cities, an occasional hyper-market out in the sticks, all bear the stamp of their foreign franchisors, compete with dhabas glorified into a tinsel  roadhouse gaudiness. These gaily-lit roadhouses reek of bad housekeeping and questionable  hygiene standards, hobbled by lack of sophistication and indifferent wares. There is an uncomfortable feeling that great roads do not do the whole trick. They seem to be a modern overlay on a sensibility struggling to catch up.  

Still, the gaudy roadhouses survive in their numerousness, across the several states I drove through, perhaps because they have large parking aprons and cater to the truckers and the villagers along the routes.
But on these new highways, there are no standardised Best Western style motels to cater to the wonders and the solaces of the open road for the middle classes. The larger petrol pumps try to provide some amenities, but all is not seamless yet. There is probably not enough demand for such infrastructure along these wonderful roads, but this could change in the future as mofussil incomes in tier two and three towns/cities rise to mirror those of the tier one metropolises. The housing estates being built alongside certainly suggest this, even if one might have to get away into the interior to see swaying mustard fields in the future.

And that final stretch, from Belgaum to Goa, under 200 km., by the coast, is a two-lane scenic road from decades ago.  The cities I passed through are bustling, but there is much inner-city decay from the years of stagnation that has been the bequest of  Socialism. These hang there still, sometimes shabby, derelict, or overtaken, but still an  eyesore on the landscape like stubborn carbuncles that refuse to be obliterated.

The contrast is stark and devastating to witness; and the disconnect between the open road of the expressways, and the higgledy-piggledy slums, the unplanned sprawl that often abuts the fancy roadways, is self-evident, if sad.

The new India will, it seems, have to completely replace the old India, lock stock and barrel, but fortunately not the ancient India of enormous wealth, wisdom and accomplishments. This post-independence oldness is not very profound, except for the fact that it mocked what was once solid, but being insubstantial itself, has run out of its luck. Not only that, it is embarrassingly clear that the Socialism of decades past has utterly failed us, and these puissant roads pulsating with trucks is a welcome departure from that  debacle of economic disappointment.

What it created, quite unintentionally, is a divorcing of the obsolete ugliness and inadequacy of the past. That stuff cannot be spliced into the present and the future. But since it has survived and exists against the odds, it must be regarded like a close relative who refuses to be locked away Jane Eyre fashion. But who nevertheless, and all too often, stamps about the stage, angst-ridden, in all its gaucherie and unrestrained squalor. It cannot, alas, be sanitised and deodorised into conformity. Indeed, all our past failures, elaborate and wrapped up in the shrink-wrap of denial, refuse to die. And present successes, considerable as they are, look like they are some distance away from  a clear ascendancy.

(928 words)
January 24th, 2014
Gautam Mukherjee


The Farexisation of the polity


The Farexisation Of The Polity

Farex is a brand of baby food that comes in little jars.  It mashes up all kinds of goodness, fortifies it with mild baby digestible boosters, and there you have it. It is for mothers who want the best for their babies in a developed world consciousness. But Farex is not the last word, or even the first word in baby rearing and nutrition. It is just high quality branded baby food manufactured and sold in most parts of the developed world. Affordability is the half of it in the once-upon-a-time ‘First World’; and convenience brings up the rear.

Drawing the analogy tighter to apply it to our desi political karta dartas in the ruling dispensation, you find yourself wondering and despairing simultaneously. It is not as if your disquiet is easy to define. After all, it comes and goes, hero and villain at the same time, but with a persistent residue of systemic decline.

If you were to ask about the sins of the Congress, for example, and its now necessary omnibus passengers in the UPA, the main thing that would stand out is not its actions, venal as many are, but its cumulative inheritance. It might have started off well enough in the glowing idealism of the independence movement, but grew noxious, and toxic, as the decades passed post- azaadi. Today it wears a face not unlike a Dorian Gray-like progression.

Rahul Gandhi is weighed down by it, this nameless evil, and this sensitivity is the single most, if not only, attractive feature of the ‘bird-brained’ scion of a diminished dynasty, or words to this effect pronounced by Pakistani-British Seventies onward London-based activist Tariq Ali. Tariq Ali also said recently that the Indian people want Modi as PM, and don’t care about the controversies being raked up by the Congress.

But Rahul Gandhi, striving to not let his side down however ineptly, does evoke a great maternal instinct and protectiveness quite disproportionate to his intrinsic political worth. It is as if he is at the very least entitled to sympathy for his dynastic predicament. It is a sort of post-modern Hamletism with the Indian people subjected to the flux.

And in the era of coalitions over the last three decades, the rot that comes from a constant distribution of the loaves and fishes of office to buy support that is traded freely, has truly set in. 

The  Indian Railways, once a proud thing, even if the British did set it up for their own colonial/imperial purposes, is today reduced to a whopping loss of Rs 25,000 crores a year on the under realisation from passenger fares alone! Once a guarded and nurtured plum of the majority wielding Congress Party, it has been too often used to mollify the hubris of this or that restive ally. Consequently, it is falling apart from ageing stock and rail,  the primitive safety standards, low utilisation and realisation, little or no modernisation, and populist additions and deletions that weaken it further.

It is, sadly, not the only institution systematically subverted by Congress’ political calculations. The CBI is not called a ‘caged parrot’ for nothing, even if its current incumbent seems to have noticed which way the wind is blowing in the matter of key NaMo aide Amit Shah being left out of the 2nd charge sheet in the Ishrat Jahan imbroglio.

The Congress  Party, in the days when it used to command a majority, out of  insecurity, lust for power, and a disrespect for the Indian Constitution it helped formulate, mashed up its institutions into running  dogs of complicity. The jury is out on the Judiciary, but enough corruption and motivated judgements have surfaced even there.

It turned almost every Government official into a yes-manning servant of its will, and with devices like the 100% dearness allowance and other perquisites of office, manages still to keep them complicit in the main. It practices a patronage system so pervasive that it has put paid to the pretence of parliamentary democracy given its six decades, more or less, in power.

Everything appears to be fixed to a lesser or greater extent well in advance. The charade causes the voting public, the ruthlessly manipulated people of this country, to vomit up its bile against this confidence trick from time to time.

Every once in a while, when it all gets too much to bear, the people throw a spanner in the works. This causes twice as expensive manoeuvres by the engines of Government, but does not dilute its basic lack of respect for the wishes of the public.  We get this public displeasure as a corrective and purging.  But it costs us in instability, clownish eruptions like the AAP, and frequent elections, economic stagnation, military vulnerability and so on. But the Congress worries only about its essentials, namely its hold on power. This lack of patriotic concern in the garb of politics as usual is probably the greatest wrong done to the country by its oldest political party.

Congress practices the art of telling the people what it is supposed to think, and does not feel the slightest embarrassment at the presumption. But it is terrified at the threat of anyone else trying out the same sorry stunt. It is not only promoting the ‘old club tie’ style cabalism, the you are required to be ‘people like us’, shorthand for the closed club, but  is hugely rattled to see its variations practiced by any other rival.

The many newsy specifics of UPA failure and Congress misrepresentation are surely legion, and will only read like an endless charge sheet of the most heartless venality. Our talking heads debate such things on TV news channels every single night till our heads spin. But the broad trends, like dishas, are much more telling. Congress and the UPA have systematically let the country down while feathering its own nests. It has been seductive in its hold, lulling the exploited public into thinking that, on the contrary, it is munificent and beneficial. It hopes the scales will never fall away from the eyes of the viewing public, for them to see their rulers for the failures they have been.

But if it progress and development our people want now, in  place of a diet of thwarted hopes and bloating lies, they need to look at the man who is offering it with both hands. They need to respond to his call, and relegate the jaded ‘Sultanate’ grown stale and useless, into the fitting dustbin of history.

(1,085 words)
February 13th, 2014

Gautam Mukherjee